Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax, Central, Gurugram vs. M/s Experion Developers Pvt. Ltd.
Background
Experion Developers, a real estate company building townships and housing, claimed about Rs. 9.70 crore of expenses as business expenditure for Assessment Year 2012-13, a year in which it recognised no income from its projects. The Assessing Officer (the tax officer who examines a return) allowed only 10% and disallowed the remaining 90%, about Rs. 8.73 crore, saying these costs should be added to the cost of projects still under construction. The first appeal authority agreed, but the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) allowed the full deduction, finding that the company had split its costs between projects and general expenses according to accepted accounting standards and had followed the same method consistently over the years.
Decision Breakdown
The High Court dismissed the department's appeal. Under Section 260A, the High Court can hear an income tax appeal only if it raises a "substantial question of law" (a genuinely debatable legal issue that affects the outcome), and the ITAT is the final authority on facts. The Court found that the ITAT had looked at the company's accounting method, how costs were allocated, the business purpose of the expenses and the relevant accounting guidance, and that its finding that the 90% cut was arbitrary was not perverse. It accepted that a partial allowance by the tax officer is not by itself proof that the whole amount is deductible, and that consistency in accounting cannot override the Act, but said the ITAT's decision also rested on its own factual findings. None of the six questions raised by the department was a substantial question of law.
Lesson Learnt
A business does not have to earn income in a particular year to deduct genuine business expenses for that year, and a tax officer cannot cut a claim by a fixed percentage on guesswork. Once the Tribunal has decided the facts on the material before it, a High Court will interfere only if a real legal question arises.