Sterlite Power Transmission Limited & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors. and connected matters
Background
Many companies, including Sterlite Power, ReNew, Jindal Stainless, Avaada Energy and GAIL, had given corporate guarantees to banks for loans taken by their subsidiaries or group companies. A corporate guarantee is a promise by one company to repay a lender if a related company fails to. From 26 October 2023, Rule 28(2) of the GST Rules fixed a deemed value of 1% of the guaranteed amount for such guarantees, and tax officers issued notices and demands on that basis. The companies challenged both the tax itself and the rule and government circulars behind it.
Decision Breakdown
The Court held that a corporate guarantee given for a related company is a "supply of services" under Section 7 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 even if no fee is charged, because the guarantor takes on the risk of default and lends its creditworthiness. Rule 28(2) is within the government's rule-making power, but making 1% a fixed minimum that can never be displaced is arbitrary and violates Article 14 of the Constitution (equality before law). The Court therefore read down the rule (narrowed its meaning to keep it valid): a lower open market value can be used if the company proves it with solid, verifiable material. The tax arises once when the guarantee is signed and again on each renewal, extension or increase, not every year. Guarantees signed before 1 July 2017 and never renewed are not taxable, those signed between 1 July 2017 and 25 October 2023 are taxable but valued under the older rules without the 1% figure, and the challenged notices and demands were set aside to that extent for fresh decision after hearing the companies.
Lesson Learnt
A free promise by a parent company to back its subsidiary's loan can still attract GST, because the law treats dealings between related parties differently. A fixed tax formula that gives the taxpayer no chance to prove a lower real value can be narrowed by the courts as unfair.