Sterlite Power Transmission Limited & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors. and connected matters

Writ Petition (Civil) · CNR No. DLHC010095132024Decided 17 Nov 2026New Delhi Bench
W.P.(C) 2966/2024, W.P.(C) 10924/2024, W.P.(C) 14622/2024, W.P.(C) 15738/2024, W.P.(C) 17559/2024, W.P.(C) 12955/2025, W.P.(C) 13341/2025, W.P.(C) 13358/2025, W.P.(C) 19506/2025, W.P.(C) 214/2025, W.P.(C) 5238/2025, W.P.(C) 6436/2025, W.P.(C) 7639/2025, W.P.(C) 8990/2025, W.P.(C) 280/2026, W.P.(C) 281/2026CNR: DLHC010095132024
Justice Anil Kshetarpal · Justice Bharat Parashar

Background

Many companies, including Sterlite Power, ReNew, Jindal Stainless, Avaada Energy and GAIL, had given corporate guarantees to banks for loans taken by their subsidiaries or group companies. A corporate guarantee is a promise by one company to repay a lender if a related company fails to. From 26 October 2023, Rule 28(2) of the GST Rules fixed a deemed value of 1% of the guaranteed amount for such guarantees, and tax officers issued notices and demands on that basis. The companies challenged both the tax itself and the rule and government circulars behind it.

Decision Breakdown

The Court held that a corporate guarantee given for a related company is a "supply of services" under Section 7 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 even if no fee is charged, because the guarantor takes on the risk of default and lends its creditworthiness. Rule 28(2) is within the government's rule-making power, but making 1% a fixed minimum that can never be displaced is arbitrary and violates Article 14 of the Constitution (equality before law). The Court therefore read down the rule (narrowed its meaning to keep it valid): a lower open market value can be used if the company proves it with solid, verifiable material. The tax arises once when the guarantee is signed and again on each renewal, extension or increase, not every year. Guarantees signed before 1 July 2017 and never renewed are not taxable, those signed between 1 July 2017 and 25 October 2023 are taxable but valued under the older rules without the 1% figure, and the challenged notices and demands were set aside to that extent for fresh decision after hearing the companies.

Lesson Learnt

A free promise by a parent company to back its subsidiary's loan can still attract GST, because the law treats dealings between related parties differently. A fixed tax formula that gives the taxpayer no chance to prove a lower real value can be narrowed by the courts as unfair.

Tax & Customs LawSupreme Court of India

Gem and Jewellery Export Promotion Council v. State of Maharashtra

The Supreme Court dismissed the Council's appeal and fully agreed with the High Court. It held that Section 2(a) of the 1923 Act says "entertainment" includes "any exhibition... to which persons are admitted for payment": the word "includes" widens the ordinary meaning, so the deciding factor is whether people pay to get in, not whether the event is fun or purely commercial. Since entry to IIJS was on payment and the shows display traders' merchandise, they fell within the definition even though they were business-to-business events; the application-and-screening process (which may serve purposes such as security) did not take the event outside the tax. The Court relied on its earlier ruling in Geeta Enterprises v. State of U.P. (1983) on the broad meaning of "entertainment".

Decided 19 Nov 2026Read case
Tax & Customs LawDelhi High Court

Commissioner of Income Tax, International Taxation-1, New Delhi vs. Emerging India Focus Funds

The question was whether gains from selling units of equity-oriented mutual funds fall under Article 13(3A) of the DTAA, which lets India tax gains from selling shares of an Indian company acquired on or after 1 April 2017. The Court held that a mutual fund unit holder is not a shareholder of any company: a unit is only an undivided interest in a fund set up as a trust, as defined in the SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations, 1996, and the unit holder has none of a shareholder's rights or liabilities. It noted that Indian tax law itself treats equity shares and units of equity-oriented funds as separate items, and relied on the Supreme Court's ruling in Apollo Tyres Ltd. v. CIT that units are not deemed shares. Rejecting the department's call for a "purposive" (intent-based) reading, it said treaty terms must be read strictly because the two countries deliberately divided taxing rights. The gains therefore fall under Article 13(4), taxable only in Mauritius, and the department's appeal was dismissed.

Decided 18 Nov 2026Read case
Tax & Customs LawDelhi High Court

Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax, Central, Gurugram vs. M/s Experion Developers Pvt. Ltd.

The High Court dismissed the department's appeal. Under Section 260A, the High Court can hear an income tax appeal only if it raises a "substantial question of law" (a genuinely debatable legal issue that affects the outcome), and the ITAT is the final authority on facts. The Court found that the ITAT had looked at the company's accounting method, how costs were allocated, the business purpose of the expenses and the relevant accounting guidance, and that its finding that the 90% cut was arbitrary was not perverse. It accepted that a partial allowance by the tax officer is not by itself proof that the whole amount is deductible, and that consistency in accounting cannot override the Act, but said the ITAT's decision also rested on its own factual findings. None of the six questions raised by the department was a substantial question of law.

Decided 18 Nov 2026Read case
Tax & Customs LawDelhi High Court

Parag Dalmia vs. Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle-1 & Anr. and connected matters

The Court held that Section 153A can be used only on the basis of incriminating material found during the search, or material found in the search that links to a document the Department already has. Here the Swiss bank document was neither found in the search nor connected to anything that was. Relying on the Supreme Court's ruling in Abhisar Buildwell and the Delhi High Court's ruling in Kabul Chawla, it said reading the provision otherwise would give the Department unchecked power, though the Department remains free to reopen the assessment under other provisions of the Act. The Court rejected the Department's argument that those rulings came after the first remand, noting that court rulings declare the law as it always stood and that Kabul Chawla predated the remand anyway. Since the Section 153A notice was bad, everything that followed fell with it, including the tax officer's reliance on Dalmia's later-retracted offer to pay tax. Both appeals were allowed and the ITAT's remand order and all later orders were set aside.

Decided 18 Nov 2026Read case
Tax & Customs LawSupreme Court of India

Sterling and Wilson Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India

The Supreme Court held that the High Court should not have brushed the writ petition aside, since the existence of an alternative appeal remedy is not a rigid bar when serious arguable points are raised; it then decided the matter itself. It held that the 70:30 rule applied only from 1 January 2019, and the 2021 circular merely gave taxpayers an option to use it for earlier years: it did not force it on anyone. Because the solar panels can be detached from their concrete foundations and used elsewhere, the systems are movable goods, so the contract was not a "works contract" (a contract to build immovable property); the Court endorsed the Andhra Pradesh High Court's consistent view on this point. As the new rule did not even exist at the time, there was no basis to allege fraud or suppression and invoke the longer limitation period under Section 74 of the CGST Act. The appeal was allowed and the tax demand orders of 17 and 24 January 2025 were set aside.

Decided 16 Nov 2026Read case
Tax & Customs LawSupreme Court of India

Arjun Flour Mills v. The State of Odisha Finance Department Secretary & Ors. (with numerous connected appeals)

The Court held the reference had become academic. The perceived conflict traced back to India Cement's premise that "royalty is a tax," a premise itself overruled by a 2024 Nine-Judge Bench ruling that royalty is contractual consideration, not a tax. With that conflict dissolved, the Court held the governing law remains its 1974 Constitution Bench ruling in S. Kodar v. State of Kerala, which held such a surcharge is simply an enhancement of the sales tax rate, within state competence. It also noted the underlying sales-tax regime has since been superseded by VAT and then GST, making the question largely of historical significance, and remitted the individual appeals to regular benches while leaving two narrower residual questions open.

Decided 4 Nov 2026Read case
Sterlite Power Transmission Limited & Ors. vs. Union of…