Devilal Gond v. State of Chhattisgarh
Background
Devilal Gond was arrested in December 2012 for murder, convicted in 2013 and sentenced to life imprisonment, but the Chhattisgarh High Court acquitted him on 20.01.2018: an acquittal the State never challenged. Because the High Court was wrongly given the impression that he was already out on bail, and the jail never learnt the result of his appeal (its 2018 letters to the legal-aid panel lawyer went unanswered), he stayed in jail for more than seven years and three months after being acquitted, until a records check led to his release on 19.05.2025. He sought Rs. 50 lakh in compensation; the High Court called the detention "wholly illegal, arbitrary" and a grave failure of the State, yet awarded only Rs. 2 lakh.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court increased the compensation from Rs. 2 lakh to Rs. 30 lakh, payable by the State of Chhattisgarh within four weeks. Relying on Nilabati Behera, Rudul Sah and D.K. Basu, it reiterated that compensation for violating the right to life and liberty under Article 21 is a public-law remedy based on strict liability, where the State cannot plead sovereign immunity, and that it is in addition to any civil suit for damages. It found the State's explanation showed "complete remissness" and institutional dysfunction, noting he lost the years from about age 28 to 35, along with livelihood, family life and opportunities, and held compensation must be meaningful enough to let him rebuild his life, not merely symbolic. To protect the money, Rs. 5 lakh goes to his savings account and the rest into an individual fixed deposit supervised by the District Legal Services Authority; the Court also asked all High Courts to consider safeguards like those adopted by the Madhya Pradesh High Court (same-day transmission of release orders to jails, regular jail inspections, and an online criminal justice data-sharing system).
Lesson Learnt
Once a court acquits you, the State must release you: keeping a person in jail through administrative "communication gaps" violates their fundamental right to liberty, and the State must pay real, substantial compensation, not a token amount. Courts can award such compensation directly in writ proceedings, without the victim having to file a separate damages suit.