Shekh Hussain @ Lekhmuddin vs. Delhi Development Authority & Ors and connected matters
Background
On 16 April 2010, two boys, Master Robiyal (about 11 and a half) and Master Arjun (about 12), died after slipping into an open sewer/manhole in a DDA park in SU Block, Pitampura, Delhi. The park was under the Delhi Development Authority (DDA) and the sewer work was being done by the Delhi Jal Board (DJB). The authorities first denied responsibility, and the police later filed a cancellation report (a report closing the criminal case), which a court accepted in 2013. In 2016 the boy's father and the other boy's mother filed writ petitions seeking compensation, and the cases stayed pending for about 10 years.
Decision Breakdown
The Court held the writ petitions maintainable because the basic facts (the deaths, the place and the open sewer) were not disputed, and sending the parents to file civil suits after a decade would be a "travesty of justice". It applied res ipsa loquitur ("the thing speaks for itself"), meaning the accident itself showed negligence, so the authorities had to prove they had taken proper care. DJB's defence of a 4-5 feet wall around the sewer failed, because an authority owes a higher duty of care in a public park and children cannot be expected to foresee hidden dangers. DDA was also held liable as the authority in charge of the park, while the police closure report was held irrelevant to a compensation claim based on the right to life, and the MCD was not held liable. Each family was awarded Rs. 11,01,000 (rounded, based on standard compensation plus loss of dependency calculated on a skilled worker's minimum wage), with 9% simple interest from the date of filing, plus Rs. 1,00,000 costs in each petition, payable jointly and severally by DDA and DJB.
Lesson Learnt
Authorities running public parks and doing civil works there must keep hazards such as sewers safely covered, and a low wall is not enough where children play. Families can seek compensation from the State through a writ petition when the facts of the death are clear, even if a police case was closed.