The Chairman, National Book Trust, India and Another v. A.R. Abdul Gaffar and Others
Background
A Delhi High Court Full Bench had held the National Book Trust, a government-established body producing affordable literature, was an other authority and therefore State under Article 12 of the Constitution, subjecting it to fundamental-rights obligations. The Trust appealed, arguing it was merely a registered trust with its own publication revenue.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court applied the cumulative test from Ajay Hasia and Pradeep Kumar Biswas, finding decisive government control: the Chairman is appointed by and serves at the Government's pleasure, Ministry representatives sit on its governing bodies, its finances run through a Government-prescribed audit framework, and rule changes require Government approval. The Trust's independent revenue didn't displace this, since the inquiry is cumulative, not factor-by-factor. The Court clarified that State status under Article 12 only triggers fundamental-rights obligations, not civil-servant status for employees.
Lesson Learnt
An organisation's label, whether society, trust, or company, doesn't shield it from constitutional accountability: what matters is the real, cumulative degree of government control over its creation, leadership, and finances.