Srinivasa T. & Ors. v. The State of Karnataka and Ors. Etc. Etc. (with connected appeals)
Background
A 2011 Karnataka civil-services recruitment for 362 posts was cancelled after a CID inquiry found rampant corruption and nepotism within the recruiting commission, a cancellation upheld by the Supreme Court in 2018. In 2022, the Karnataka legislature passed a validation Act attempting to revive and validate the already judicially-cancelled selections, and 191 candidates were appointed under it. Qualified candidates left out due to age-limit issues during the litigation challenged the Act; the High Court dismissed their challenge.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court held the validation Act unconstitutional, ruling a legislature can retrospectively cure a legal defect a court identified, but cannot nullify or override a specific final judgment between specific parties, that violates the separation of powers. Since the recruitment was invalidated for substantive corruption, not a mere procedural defect, there was no "defect" left to cure; the Act simply tried to legislatively overturn binding judgments. As relief, the Court directed fresh recruitment for the vacant posts, with a one-time age relaxation for untainted earlier candidates, but no back wages or retrospective seniority for anyone reselected.
Lesson Learnt
A legislature cannot use a validating law to directly overturn a final court judgment in a specific dispute: political change cannot be used to legislatively "undo" a judicially-established finding of corruption in public recruitment, even years later and even to relieve hardship on the corrupt process's beneficiaries.