Rabi Ghosh vs. New Delhi Municipal Council

Letters Patent Appeal · 2026:DHC:8146-DBDecided 21 Sept 2026New Delhi Bench
LPA 750/2026CNR: DLHC010449302026
Chief Justice Devendra Kumar Upadhyaya · Justice Tejas Karia

Background

The appellant held a license from the New Delhi Municipal Council (NDMC) for a shop-cum-flat on Lodhi Road since 1997, later renewed in his sole name in 2013. While the license was in force, he mortgaged the property to a finance company for a loan, and separately, in a money-decree execution case against him, he agreed by a Memorandum of Understanding to hand the same property over to a decree-holder to settle his debt. When NDMC found out about these dealings, it refused to renew his license, and a Single Judge of the High Court upheld that refusal, also finding that the appellant's later attempt to "cancel" his settlement with the decree-holder was a fraudulent afterthought.

Decision Breakdown

The Division Bench (hearing the appeal against the Single Judge's decision) agreed that the appellant had acted deceitfully, first offering the licensed property as loan collateral, then agreeing to hand it to a decree-holder, both of which violated the terms of his license (which did not permit such dealings), and that his later "cancellation" of the settlement was manufactured only after NDMC challenged the earlier order, to make renewal easier. The Court held that a public authority like NDMC is not obligated to renew a license to someone who has misused the property in this manner, and dismissed the appeal with Rs. 50,000 in costs.

Lesson Learnt

A tenant or licensee of government/public property who pledges or otherwise deals with that property inconsistently with their license terms (e.g., using it as loan collateral, or agreeing to hand it to a creditor) risks losing their right to renewal: courts will look closely at the full history of such dealings, not just the applicant's stated intentions at any one point.

Civil Property & InheritanceSupreme Court of India

J. Rajesh (Minor) Thr. His Mother and Natural Guardian J. Gomathi v. M. Kumaran (Dead) Thr. LRs. and Ors.

The Supreme Court upheld the High Court, holding that under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, intestate succession passes property to the individually named heirs: a son inherits it as his own absolute property, not as joint family property, so it doesn't automatically become ancestral property in which his own son gains a birthright share. Since the grandfather's property had already been partitioned among his heirs, the father's share was his exclusive personal property before the minor's claim could arise.

Decided 6 Nov 2026Read case
Civil Property & InheritanceSupreme Court of India

Rama Pandey and Others v. Ram Lal (Dead) Through LR. and Others

The Supreme Court upheld the High Court. The appellants never held any right in the land, the spot inspection credibly established its commercial roadside character, and the Deputy Director had failed to engage with these facts or the governing circulars protecting original tenure holders. The Court also rejected the appellants' limitation argument, holding that procedural delay doesn't cure an allotment order otherwise shown to be illegal.

Decided 5 Nov 2026Read case
Civil Property & InheritanceSupreme Court of India

Girishbhai Natwarlal Patel v. Gautam Punjabhai Palkhiwala (Dead) by LRs & Ors.

The Supreme Court upheld the High Court on all three points. The interim injunction was valid even though granted before the delay and leave applications were decided, given the suspicious circumstances and risk the land could be sold off. On maintainability, the Court clarified that the usual bar on appealing a consent decree binds only those who were parties to the compromise: it doesn't stop a genuinely aggrieved outsider whose own rights are prejudiced. On delay, since the family only learned of the decree's effect on their rights in 2023 and acted promptly thereafter, condonation was proper. The Court decided only these procedural questions, directing the High Court to resolve the underlying fraud allegations within three months.

Decided 30 Oct 2026Read case
Civil Property & InheritanceSupreme Court of India

Bandari Ramchander & Ors. v. Maitri Coop. Housing Society Ltd. & Ors. (with connected matters)

The Supreme Court dismissed all the appeals, holding that any rights under the Nizam-era grant were extinguished when the land vested in the State under the Abolition of Jagirs Regulation, 1949. Revenue entries recording one claimant as title-holder were made years after vesting without any valid transfer order and were found to be "bogus," reflecting fraud in collusion with revenue officials: a 1995 inspection had found the land vacant wasteland. A newly-raised 1918 auction-and-will claim was rejected as unproven, never having surfaced in over a century of prior proceedings.

Decided 29 Oct 2026Read case
Civil Property & InheritanceDelhi High Court

Somnath Kharbanda (deceased, through LRs) & Anr. vs. Arvinder Kaur (deceased, through LRs) & Ors.

The High Court held that under Section 74 of the Indian Contract Act, forfeiting an earnest-money deposit is not automatic: the party keeping the money must prove it actually suffered a genuine, provable loss. The sellers' claimed loss on another property deal went unproven at trial (originals never produced, no corroborating testimony). Since the sellers failed to prove any actual loss, they had no legal basis to keep the deposit, and the appeal was dismissed.

Decided 27 Oct 2026Read case
Civil Property & InheritanceSupreme Court of India

Balakrishna (Dead) Thr. LRs. v. G.N. Kanniah Naidu (Dead) Thr. LRs. and Another

The Supreme Court reversed, finding the lower courts had the evidence backwards: the resisting party's son had produced the original title document, while the decree-holder had never produced anything but an unadmitted photocopy. Possession of the original document, not tax receipts, was the real indicator of title. The Court also held that a person never made party to a suit over "their" land is entitled to resist execution directly rather than being forced into a fresh suit, since the law specifically bars that separate-suit route.

Decided 26 Oct 2026Read case