Bharat Bhushan Jain (Dead) Through LRs v. Goodyear India Ltd.
Background
The owners of premises at 1, Ansari Road, Daryaganj, New Delhi had let them to Goodyear India Ltd., and terminated the tenancy with effect from 31.12.1989. They sued in 1990 for possession and for damages for the tenant's continued occupation, claiming Rs. 1,47,500 per month plus 15% interest; the eviction decree became final in 2001, leaving only the amount of "mesne profits" (compensation a wrongful occupant pays the owner for the period of unauthorised stay) to be decided. The Trial Court fixed it at Rs. 22 per sq. ft. per month (ground floor) and Rs. 11 (mezzanine) with 15% interest, relying on rent paid by Vijaya Bank for a nearby building; the First Appellate Court rejected that comparison and limited the owners to the old rent; and the Delhi High Court (11.08.2011) fixed Rs. 7 and Rs. 5 per sq. ft. per month with 7.5% simple interest (6% if paid within two months). The owners appealed seeking a higher amount.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court dismissed the appeals and upheld the High Court's figures. It explained that mesne profits are compensatory, have no rigid formula, and must be a fair estimate based on the property's nature, location, prevailing rents and evidence, and that appellate courts should not interfere unless the assessment is arbitrary or unsupported. The High Court had rightly corrected the First Appellate Court's failure to consider an admission by Goodyear's own witness that local rents at the time were Rs. 5 to Rs. 8 per sq. ft. per month, and its rates fell within that range; the Vijaya Bank premises (newer, used as a bank) were not a fair comparison for an old godown. The Court also upheld the interest award, noting that interest is an integral part of mesne profits, and stressed that a dispute running over three decades deserved finality.
Lesson Learnt
A tenant who stays on after the tenancy ends must compensate the owner at a fair market-based rate, not merely the old rent, but the owner must prove that rate with reliable, genuinely comparable evidence. Admissions made by a party's own witness can decide the figure.