M/s Universal Steel Supply Co & Ors. vs. Shri Pawan Kumar Saraf & Ors.
Background
A steel trading firm had used the middle portion of a plot in Loha Mandi, Naraina, Delhi since 1994 under a series of written agreements, paying the owners a commission of Rs. 25 per metric tonne of sales. The owners said this was a licence (permission to use the space, with legal possession staying with the owner), which ended in 2004. They served a notice in 2005 and filed a suit for possession in 2010. The firm claimed it was a protected tenant paying Rs. 2,500 a month, so the case could only be heard under the Delhi Rent Control Act. In March 2026 the District Judge ordered possession on the basis of the firm's own admissions, while the firm's witness was still being cross-examined.
Decision Breakdown
The High Court held that the Delhi Rent Control Act did not apply because what was let out was an open plot with a temporary tin shed, which is not "premises" under Section 2(i) of that Act, so the bar in Section 50 did not apply and an ordinary civil suit was maintainable. Looking at the agreements, the commission-based payments and the site plan, it held the arrangement was a licence, not a tenancy, and one cheque accepted by a co-owner did not create a new tenancy. In earlier arbitration proceedings the firm had itself admitted the commission arrangement, and those admissions still counted even though the arbitral award was later set aside on the ground of how the arbitrator was appointed. Since the arrangement was validly ended by the 2005 notice, the Court held a decree on admissions under Order XII Rule 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure was proper even at a late stage of evidence, because recording evidence on admitted facts serves no purpose. The appeal was dismissed.
Lesson Learnt
What a person admits in one set of legal proceedings can be used against them later in another case about the same property. Whether an arrangement is a licence or a tenancy depends on its real terms and the parties' conduct. The label one side gives it later does not decide the question.