Kishan Murari vs. The State (Govt of NCT of Delhi) & Ors
Background
A son asked a Delhi trial court for probate (official court recognition of a Will) of a Will said to have been made by his mother on 5 May 2006, two days before she died, leaving her house in Laxmi Nagar to him. His two sisters objected, saying the Will was forged and that their mother was too ill to make it. The trial court found no proof of forgery but still dismissed the son's petition. The reason was that the original Will was never shown to either of the two attesting witnesses (the people who sign a Will to confirm they saw it being signed) when they gave evidence. One witness was shown only a photocopy.
Decision Breakdown
The High Court first condoned (excused) the 49-day delay in filing the appeal. It agreed that the Will had not yet been proved as the law requires: Section 63(c) of the Indian Succession Act and Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 need at least one attesting witness to confirm the signing of the very document before the court, and identifying signatures on a photocopy does not prove the original. However, the Court found the gap came from an oversight in how the witnesses were questioned, not from a lack of evidence. The original Will had been on the court file from the start, both witnesses were alive and had supported it in their affidavits, and the sisters never objected at the time. Relying on the Supreme Court's decision in M. B. Ramesh, it held that a testator's wishes should not be defeated by a technicality, and sent the case back to the trial court only on the question of whether the Will was validly executed. The son may recall both witnesses to be shown the original Will, the sisters may cross-examine them again, and the finding that the Will was not forged stays untouched. The parties were told to appear before the trial court on 8 December 2026.
Lesson Learnt
To prove a Will in court, at least one attesting witness must be shown the original document and confirm the signatures on it. A photocopy is not enough. Where the slip is a procedural one and the evidence exists, a court may allow it to be corrected rather than throw out the Will.