Mohd. Taqi vs. Shujauddin
Background
Shujauddin bought the first and second floors (with roof rights) of a building in Gali Matia Mahal, Jama Masjid, Delhi through a registered sale deed in 1989. His paternal uncle, Mohd. Taqi, had lived in part of it for decades and was allowed to stay on without paying anything. In 2021 the nephew ended this permission by legal notice and sued for possession. The uncle claimed he owned his portion under a 1974 Hibanama (a gift deed under Muslim law) from his father, and alternatively by adverse possession (ownership claimed through long, open and hostile occupation). In April 2026 the District Judge ordered him to vacate and pay Rs. 8,000 a month for use of the property from November 2021.
Decision Breakdown
The High Court held that a registered sale deed is presumed validly executed, and the uncle produced no evidence that it was forged; the deed also explained the seller's own title. Under Section 129 of the Transfer of Property Act, a Hiba need not be registered, but it can only pass what the giver owns, and the uncle admitted he had no document showing his father ever owned the property. The Court held that a family member's permission to live in a house is a licence that need not be in writing, and that filing a suit for possession itself ends a licence, so the dispute over receipt of the notice did not matter. Long stay alone does not create adverse possession: the uncle never showed when his occupation became hostile to the owner, and he had never paid property tax. Finally, Section 19 of the Slum Areas (Improvement and Clearance) Act, 1956, which requires official permission before evicting someone in a slum area, protects only tenants in law, not licensees or other occupants. The appeal was dismissed.
Lesson Learnt
Living in a relative's property for many years with their permission does not make a person its owner. To claim adverse possession, a person must prove when and how they openly began occupying the property against the owner's rights. A long stay on its own is not enough.