U.P. Avas Evam Vikas Parishad v. Gaursons India Pvt. Ltd.
Background
The U.P. Housing Board acquired 12.047 acres in Ghaziabad for its Vasundhara Scheme; under a 1995 compromise recorded by the Supreme Court, the owners were to get equivalent land in exchange with no money changing hands. The replacement land given in 2004 turned out to be a lake and barren land already earmarked for a bird sanctuary, so it could never be used; Gaursons, which had bought the owners' rights in 2005 for Rs. 12 crore, eventually received a different residential plot in Siddharth Vihar under a 2016 exchange deed after paying Rs. 32.45 crore in conversion charges, and built 2,476 homes plus 450 EWS/LIG flats there. In 2022 the Chief Secretary ordered that the plot be charged at the current bulk-sale rate and that land use restrictions be reimposed, and the Housing Board raised a demand of Rs. 388 crore; the Allahabad High Court struck these down.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court dismissed the State's and Housing Board's appeals and upheld the High Court. It held that the 1995 condition limiting use to water-purification works applied only to the original acquired land, and since the 2004 exchange failed entirely because of the Housing Board's own lack of due diligence, its conditions could not be carried over to the fresh 2016 deed, which expressly granted a freehold residential plot. The 2016 deed itself said no value or consideration was payable, the Board had kept and developed the more valuable original land without paying compensation, and Gaursons had already paid conversion charges, so the Rs. 388 crore demand could not stand. The Court expressed no opinion on a Special Investigation Team report alleging collusion with officials, leaving authorities free to act on it in accordance with law, and gave the State three more months to decide the allotment of the 450 EWS/LIG flats.
Lesson Learnt
When a government body promises land in exchange for land it has taken, it must hand over usable, unencumbered land; if its own mistake makes the first exchange fail, it cannot later impose old restrictions or fresh charges on the substitute land that its own registered deed did not provide for. A person who buys land with title also acquires any rights that come with it, such as the right to receive replacement land.