Akshay Puri vs. Mr. Kailash Kumar Arora
Background
K.K. Arora, a 76-year-old Canadian citizen of Indian origin, inherited a house in Vasant Vihar, New Delhi from his mother. Around 2000-2001, out of love for his sister, he let her and her family live in the basement and ground floor without paying rent. After his sister died in 2013, her husband and son stayed on. In March 2018 he withdrew his permission and asked them to leave by 15 April 2018, and when they did not, he sued for possession and mesne profits (compensation for the period someone stays on a property without a right to). The family claimed an oral family settlement, a Will in the sister's favour, an arrangement over a joint bank account, and in the alternative ownership by adverse possession (ownership claimed through long, hostile occupation). The District Judge decided the case on the family's own admissions without a full trial, ordering possession and Rs. 3,00,000 a month in mesne profits.
Decision Breakdown
The High Court held that the family had admitted in their own written statement that Mr. Arora was the owner and that they lived there with his permission. A "family settlement" needs each side to have some earlier claim to the property; since the sister had none, any transfer of ownership could only happen through a registered sale or gift deed under Sections 54 and 123 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. A Will takes effect only after the maker dies, and since Mr. Arora is alive and the sister died before him, it gave them nothing. The adverse possession plea failed because they never said when or how their occupation became hostile to the owner, and occupation that begins with permission does not turn into ownership merely because time passes. The decree for possession under Order XII Rule 6 CPC was upheld, but the Rs. 3,00,000 monthly figure was set aside because it rested on unproved copies of other lease deeds, and the matter was sent back for an inquiry under Order XX Rule 12 CPC, with parties to appear on 7 December 2026.
Lesson Learnt
Letting a relative live in your house free of charge does not give them ownership, however long they stay. Once the owner withdraws permission, they must leave and can be made to pay for the period they stay on, but the amount must be proved with evidence, not fixed on unproved documents.