Bibol Toppo v. State of Odisha

Civil Appeal · 2026 INSC 1244Decided 18 Nov 2026
Civil Appeal No. 8294 of 2026
Justice Dipankar Datta · Justice Satish Chandra Sharma

Background

Dalmia Cements held a state mining lease (extended to 2040) over a large area in Sundergarh district, Odisha, but to mine a further 273.57 Ha spread over the villages of Kukuda, Bihabandha and Lanjiberna it also needed the surface rights, which belonged to local landholders. At the company's request, the State began acquiring this land in 2015 under the 2013 land acquisition law (the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act). The area is a tribal "Scheduled Area" under the Fifth Schedule of the Constitution, and the Gram Sabhas (village assemblies) unanimously rejected the proposal on 26 January 2020, yet the State went ahead and issued final acquisition notifications in 2021. The Orissa High Court dismissed the villagers' challenge in 2024, treating the consent requirements as non-mandatory.

Decision Breakdown

The Supreme Court set aside the High Court's judgment and quashed the acquisition and all related notifications. Because the land was being acquired for the exclusive use of a private mining company, the law required the prior consent of at least 80% of affected families, obtained in the prescribed form (Form J) alongside the social impact study and before the government's review: consent collected later "as a continuing process" does not count. Separately, Section 41(3) makes prior consent of the Gram Sabha mandatory for any acquisition in a Scheduled Area, and here the Gram Sabhas had expressly refused. The Court also found that no genuine public hearing on the draft social impact report took place, and that the supposedly independent expert group was compromised because it included the company's own land-acquisition adviser; a mining lease between the State and a company cannot override landowners' rights under the 2013 Act. The State remains free to start a fresh acquisition that follows the law.

Lesson Learnt

When the government acquires land for a private company, it must first secure the prior consent of most affected families, and in tribal Scheduled Areas the village Gram Sabha's prior consent is compulsory, not a formality that can be skipped or obtained after the fact. A mining lease does not let a company bypass the legal rights of the people who actually own and use the land.

Civil Property & InheritanceSupreme Court of India

Bharat Bhushan Jain (Dead) Through LRs v. Goodyear India Ltd.

The Supreme Court dismissed the appeals and upheld the High Court's figures. It explained that mesne profits are compensatory, have no rigid formula, and must be a fair estimate based on the property's nature, location, prevailing rents and evidence, and that appellate courts should not interfere unless the assessment is arbitrary or unsupported. The High Court had rightly corrected the First Appellate Court's failure to consider an admission by Goodyear's own witness that local rents at the time were Rs. 5 to Rs. 8 per sq. ft. per month, and its rates fell within that range; the Vijaya Bank premises (newer, used as a bank) were not a fair comparison for an old godown. The Court also upheld the interest award, noting that interest is an integral part of mesne profits, and stressed that a dispute running over three decades deserved finality.

Decided 18 Nov 2026Read case
Civil Property & InheritanceDelhi High Court

Kishan Murari vs. The State (Govt of NCT of Delhi) & Ors

The High Court first condoned (excused) the 49-day delay in filing the appeal. It agreed that the Will had not yet been proved as the law requires: Section 63(c) of the Indian Succession Act and Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 need at least one attesting witness to confirm the signing of the very document before the court, and identifying signatures on a photocopy does not prove the original. However, the Court found the gap came from an oversight in how the witnesses were questioned, not from a lack of evidence. The original Will had been on the court file from the start, both witnesses were alive and had supported it in their affidavits, and the sisters never objected at the time. Relying on the Supreme Court's decision in M. B. Ramesh, it held that a testator's wishes should not be defeated by a technicality, and sent the case back to the trial court only on the question of whether the Will was validly executed. The son may recall both witnesses to be shown the original Will, the sisters may cross-examine them again, and the finding that the Will was not forged stays untouched. The parties were told to appear before the trial court on 8 December 2026.

Decided 18 Nov 2026Read case
Civil Property & InheritanceDelhi High Court

Akshay Puri vs. Mr. Kailash Kumar Arora

The High Court held that the family had admitted in their own written statement that Mr. Arora was the owner and that they lived there with his permission. A "family settlement" needs each side to have some earlier claim to the property; since the sister had none, any transfer of ownership could only happen through a registered sale or gift deed under Sections 54 and 123 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. A Will takes effect only after the maker dies, and since Mr. Arora is alive and the sister died before him, it gave them nothing. The adverse possession plea failed because they never said when or how their occupation became hostile to the owner, and occupation that begins with permission does not turn into ownership merely because time passes. The decree for possession under Order XII Rule 6 CPC was upheld, but the Rs. 3,00,000 monthly figure was set aside because it rested on unproved copies of other lease deeds, and the matter was sent back for an inquiry under Order XX Rule 12 CPC, with parties to appear on 7 December 2026.

Decided 18 Nov 2026Read case
Civil Property & InheritanceSupreme Court of India

U.P. Avas Evam Vikas Parishad v. Gaursons India Pvt. Ltd.

The Supreme Court dismissed the State's and Housing Board's appeals and upheld the High Court. It held that the 1995 condition limiting use to water-purification works applied only to the original acquired land, and since the 2004 exchange failed entirely because of the Housing Board's own lack of due diligence, its conditions could not be carried over to the fresh 2016 deed, which expressly granted a freehold residential plot. The 2016 deed itself said no value or consideration was payable, the Board had kept and developed the more valuable original land without paying compensation, and Gaursons had already paid conversion charges, so the Rs. 388 crore demand could not stand. The Court expressed no opinion on a Special Investigation Team report alleging collusion with officials, leaving authorities free to act on it in accordance with law, and gave the State three more months to decide the allotment of the 450 EWS/LIG flats.

Decided 17 Nov 2026Read case
Civil Property & InheritanceDelhi High Court

Mohd. Taqi vs. Shujauddin

The High Court held that a registered sale deed is presumed validly executed, and the uncle produced no evidence that it was forged; the deed also explained the seller's own title. Under Section 129 of the Transfer of Property Act, a Hiba need not be registered, but it can only pass what the giver owns, and the uncle admitted he had no document showing his father ever owned the property. The Court held that a family member's permission to live in a house is a licence that need not be in writing, and that filing a suit for possession itself ends a licence, so the dispute over receipt of the notice did not matter. Long stay alone does not create adverse possession: the uncle never showed when his occupation became hostile to the owner, and he had never paid property tax. Finally, Section 19 of the Slum Areas (Improvement and Clearance) Act, 1956, which requires official permission before evicting someone in a slum area, protects only tenants in law, not licensees or other occupants. The appeal was dismissed.

Decided 17 Nov 2026Read case
Civil Property & InheritanceDelhi High Court

M/s Universal Steel Supply Co & Ors. vs. Shri Pawan Kumar Saraf & Ors.

The High Court held that the Delhi Rent Control Act did not apply because what was let out was an open plot with a temporary tin shed, which is not "premises" under Section 2(i) of that Act, so the bar in Section 50 did not apply and an ordinary civil suit was maintainable. Looking at the agreements, the commission-based payments and the site plan, it held the arrangement was a licence, not a tenancy, and one cheque accepted by a co-owner did not create a new tenancy. In earlier arbitration proceedings the firm had itself admitted the commission arrangement, and those admissions still counted even though the arbitral award was later set aside on the ground of how the arbitrator was appointed. Since the arrangement was validly ended by the 2005 notice, the Court held a decree on admissions under Order XII Rule 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure was proper even at a late stage of evidence, because recording evidence on admitted facts serves no purpose. The appeal was dismissed.

Decided 17 Nov 2026Read case
Bibol Toppo v. State of Odisha – Case Summary