Sunil Kumar vs. M/S Delhi Metro Rail Corporation Ltd.

Writ Petition (Civil) · 2026:DHC:7892Decided 16 Sept 2026New Delhi Bench
W.P.(C) 1075/2017CNR: DLHC010335542017
Justice Amit Mahajan

Background

Sunil Kumar, a DMRC driver, was removed from service in 2009 after being found guilty of three instances of misconduct: misbehaving with a senior officer and driving rashly when questioned about a leave application, unauthorized absence from duty while visiting a nursing home and arguing with a senior official, and failing to comply with an instruction to distribute internal mail (dak) and generally behaving discourteously. His internal departmental appeal and review were both rejected, and an industrial tribunal later upheld his removal after DMRC independently proved the charges with fresh witness testimony (since the original internal inquiry had been found procedurally flawed).

Decision Breakdown

The High Court held that its power to review the tribunal's factual findings is very limited, and it would not re-weigh evidence just because another view was possible. It upheld the tribunal's findings that all three charges of misconduct were proved through credible witness testimony, rejecting the driver's technical objections (such as an attendance register not showing his name, which if anything supported the charge of unauthorized absence). However, the Court excluded from consideration one aspect of the evidence: testimony about a 2010 incident that occurred after his removal, which the tribunal itself had earlier ruled irrelevant but then still referenced. Despite upholding the misconduct findings, the Court found the punishment of outright removal "shockingly disproportionate" given the relatively minor nature of the proven acts and his 8-9 years of otherwise satisfactory service.

Lesson Learnt

Even where a court agrees that workplace misconduct occurred, it can still step in to correct a punishment that is grossly disproportionate to the offence, though since 17 years had passed, the driver was awarded a lump-sum payment of ₹3,00,000 instead of reinstatement, illustrating that with very long delays, courts prefer practical compensation over reversing time.

Labour & Industrial LawDelhi High Court

Mool Chand Khairati Ram Hospital vs. Indiver

The Court found no flaw in the tribunal's ruling that the 1998 abolition breached statutory protection for an active union representative during a pending dispute, and upheld that finding. But since Indiver had already been reinstated, received back-wages, and was separately terminated again on different grounds (which he remains free to challenge separately), reinstatement had been overtaken by events. The Court converted the surviving dispute into a lump-sum Rs. 3,00,000 compensation.

Decided 27 Oct 2026Read case
Labour & Industrial LawDelhi High Court

Delhi Transport Corporation vs. Suresh Chand

The Court agreed DTC's own witness admitted the leave applications were never looked at: the "show cause" process was a hollow formality, not genuine consideration as natural justice requires. The regulation DTC relied on was itself later declared unconstitutional and withdrawn. Since Suresh Chand had reached retirement age and already received a large recovered sum, the Court modified relief from reinstatement to a lump-sum Rs. 2,00,000 compensation.

Decided 27 Oct 2026Read case
Labour & Industrial LawDelhi High Court

Suresh Pal vs. National Council of Applied Economic Research

The High Court agreed that his role was tied to a defined, fixed-term project rather than being permanent. Because his exit fell under a specific legal exception for genuine fixed-term or project contracts, it did not count as "retrenchment," so the employer didn't need to follow the retrenchment procedure. The Court also noted its Article 227 review power is narrow and won't disturb findings that aren't perverse. The petition was dismissed and the award upheld.

Decided 14 Oct 2026Read case
Labour & Industrial LawDelhi High Court

Indian Oil Corporation Ltd vs. Raj Kumar

The Court held that Section 11A of the Industrial Disputes Act expressly empowers a Labour Court to modify a disproportionate punishment even where the misconduct itself is proved. Since the Tribunal had not disturbed the finding of guilt and had only exercised its discretion on quantum, considering the workman's long service and disability, the Court found this to be a plausible and reasoned view. A writ court exercising supervisory jurisdiction does not substitute its own view merely because another view on punishment is also possible.

Decided 17 Sept 2026Read case
Labour & Industrial LawDelhi High Court

DTC vs. Shri Braham Prakash

The Court held that a writ court exercising supervisory jurisdiction cannot re-appreciate evidence like an appellate court, and can interfere only if the Tribunal's view was not a plausible one. It found the Tribunal's reasoning sound: the surrendered "unpunched tickets" bore signatures that didn't match the conductor's admitted signature, casting doubt on the management's case, and the sole checking-staff witness was uncorroborated. However, since more than three decades had passed, the workman had already reached superannuation, and he had been paid wages under Section 17-B of the Industrial Disputes Act throughout, the Court held reinstatement itself was no longer appropriate. It modified the award to a lumpsum compensation of Rs. 4,00,000 in lieu of reinstatement.

Decided 17 Sept 2026Read case
Labour & Industrial LawDelhi High Court

Varun Juneja vs. Soniya

The High Court revised the compensation upward, since the employer had itself admitted paying the deceased Rs. 18,000 per month (not the lower Rs. 15,000 minimum-wage figure the Commissioner had used), raising the total compensation to Rs. 15,57,680. On the separate question of penalty, the employer argued the maximum 50% penalty was too harsh, but the Court upheld it, noting the employer only deposited money after the family was forced to start recovery proceedings, more than three and a half years after the death, with no voluntary payment at any point.

Decided 17 Sept 2026Read case