Anand Saraswat vs. Kailash Soni
Background
A guest-house owner sued for unpaid stay charges; the defendant claimed he'd already paid more than claimed. The trial court ordered him to deposit Rs. 15 lakh as security, reasoning he lived outside Delhi with no local assets.
Decision Breakdown
The High Court held this drastic power requires actual evidence the defendant is trying to hide or dispose of assets to dodge a future decree, not just general apprehension. Living outside the jurisdiction or filing evasive denials didn't show such intent, especially since he was actively participating in the case. The order was set aside.
Lesson Learnt
A court cannot force a defendant to deposit security merely because the claim looks plausible or he lives elsewhere: there must be real evidence of intent to dodge a future judgment.