Harish Kumar vs. Yatender Arora and Ors
Background
The landlords sued their tenant, Harish Kumar, in a commercial court in Rohini for eviction and about Rs. 28.62 lakh in unpaid rent for floors of a building in Indira Vikas Colony. On 7 May 2025 the trial court ordered the tenant to deposit Rs. 35,13,900 in rent arrears for the period after the suit was filed, under Order XXXIX Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), which lets a court order money in dispute to be deposited. The tenant did not appeal that order in time. Instead, he challenged it in the High Court using its supervisory power under Article 227 of the Constitution, saying he had paid in cash without receipts and had spent over Rs. 50 lakh on renovation.
Decision Breakdown
The Court held that the only question was whether such a petition could be heard at all. An order under Order XXXIX Rule 10 CPC can be appealed under Order XLIII Rule 1(r) CPC, and in a commercial case that appeal goes to the Commercial Appellate Division under Section 13(1A) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015. Relying on Supreme Court rulings including Virudhunagar Hindu Nadargal Dharma Paribalana Sabai and P. Suresh v. D. Kalaivani, the Court said that where the CPC itself gives a right of appeal, it acts as a "near total bar" on using Article 227, which cannot be used to get around the appeal route or its time limit. As no exceptional circumstance was shown, the petition was dismissed at the outset as not maintainable, without any view on the merits, and the tenant was left free to pursue any other remedy available in law.
Lesson Learnt
If the law gives a specific right of appeal against a court order, that appeal must be filed within its time limit. The High Court will not ordinarily let a party use its supervisory power as a substitute for a missed appeal.