VLCC Personal Care Limited vs. Sudhir Solvent Private Limited
Background
A supplier sued VLCC Personal Care in a Delhi commercial court in 2021 to recover about Rs. 1.69 crore for goods supplied. Summons was sent by WhatsApp to the company's Chief Business Officer in February 2022, and in July 2022 the plaint (the written claim) and documents were emailed to five company email addresses, including the registered email address shown in the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) records. VLCC filed no written statement (its written reply to the claim), so in September 2022 the trial court struck off its defence. VLCC said it found the email in its spam folder in October 2022 and sought a recall of that order, which was refused, so it came to the High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution.
Decision Breakdown
The Court agreed with VLCC that the February 2022 WhatsApp service was defective, because it carried only a photo of the summons without the plaint, as Order V Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) requires. But it held that the July 2022 email service was valid, since it was sent to the company's MCA-registered email address and to four other addresses listed in the suit papers, and VLCC showed nothing to prove it could not access them. A company must keep access to the email address it registers with the MCA, and must update it if it changes. Following the Supreme Court's ruling in SCG Contracts India, the 120-day limit under Order VIII Rule 1 CPC for commercial suits is strict, and VLCC's 120 days ran out on 20 November 2022, before it moved the court on 22 November 2022. The petition was dismissed and VLCC lost its right to file a written statement.
Lesson Learnt
A company's official email address registered with the government is a valid address for court papers, and saying a mail went to spam will not excuse missing a deadline. In commercial cases, the 120-day limit to file a written reply is strict and cannot be extended.