Economic Transport Organisation vs. M/s New India Assurance Co. Ltd. & Anr.
Background
A consignment of medicines worth over Rs. 43 lakh, entrusted to a transport firm in 1999, never reached its destination. The insurer paid the consignor and sued the transport firm, winning a 2012 decree from the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission. During execution, the transport company argued the old partnership had dissolved in 2006 and liability should be apportioned among 17 former partners before enforcement.
Decision Breakdown
The National Commission had repeatedly asked for dissolution documents and partner details before ruling no apportionment was needed before execution. The High Court held its Article 227 power is narrow: it can't re-examine facts or act as an appellate court, and one of the two challenged orders was appealable only to the Supreme Court. Once a decree is final, a judgment-debtor can't use execution to reopen the liability the decree fixed. The petition was dismissed.
Lesson Learnt
Once a decree becomes final, you cannot use the execution stage to relitigate liability: objections must be raised before the decree is passed.