Balar Marketing Private Limited vs. Samsubramani Proprietor, Kalalakar Agencies
Background
Balar Marketing, a Delhi-registered company selling fans, wires and other electrical goods, supplied goods from its Chennai warehouse to a Chennai retailer, Kalalakar Agencies, between 2018 and 2024. It claimed Rs. 8,79,206 was unpaid and filed a commercial suit in the Karkardooma Courts, Delhi. The Commercial Court returned the plaint (sent the case papers back) under Order VII Rule 10 CPC, saying Delhi courts had no territorial jurisdiction (power over cases connected to that place) and the case should be filed in Chennai.
Decision Breakdown
The company argued that its invoices said Delhi courts would decide disputes, and that the buyer had made payments into its Delhi bank account. The High Court refused to consider the invoice clause because it had not been raised before the trial court and the invoices were not even filed, adding that such a clause cannot give jurisdiction to a court that otherwise has none. Under Section 20 CPC, a suit can be filed where the contract was made, performed, or where payment was due. On the company's own case, the invoices named a Chennai bank account for payment, the goods moved from Chennai to Chennai, and payments landing in a Delhi account without any agreement on Delhi as the place of payment did not give Delhi courts jurisdiction. The appeal was dismissed.
Lesson Learnt
A business cannot sue in its home city only because its head office or bank account is there. The case usually has to be filed where the deal was made, carried out, or where payment was agreed to be made, so that the other side is not dragged to a distant court it never agreed to.