Balar Marketing Private Limited vs. Samsubramani Proprietor, Kalalakar Agencies

First Appeal from Order (Commercial) · CNR No. DLHC010469682026Decided 18 Nov 2026New Delhi Bench
FAO (COMM) 293/2026CNR: DLHC010469682026
Justice Subramonium Prasad · Justice Renu Bhatnagar

Background

Balar Marketing, a Delhi-registered company selling fans, wires and other electrical goods, supplied goods from its Chennai warehouse to a Chennai retailer, Kalalakar Agencies, between 2018 and 2024. It claimed Rs. 8,79,206 was unpaid and filed a commercial suit in the Karkardooma Courts, Delhi. The Commercial Court returned the plaint (sent the case papers back) under Order VII Rule 10 CPC, saying Delhi courts had no territorial jurisdiction (power over cases connected to that place) and the case should be filed in Chennai.

Decision Breakdown

The company argued that its invoices said Delhi courts would decide disputes, and that the buyer had made payments into its Delhi bank account. The High Court refused to consider the invoice clause because it had not been raised before the trial court and the invoices were not even filed, adding that such a clause cannot give jurisdiction to a court that otherwise has none. Under Section 20 CPC, a suit can be filed where the contract was made, performed, or where payment was due. On the company's own case, the invoices named a Chennai bank account for payment, the goods moved from Chennai to Chennai, and payments landing in a Delhi account without any agreement on Delhi as the place of payment did not give Delhi courts jurisdiction. The appeal was dismissed.

Lesson Learnt

A business cannot sue in its home city only because its head office or bank account is there. The case usually has to be filed where the deal was made, carried out, or where payment was agreed to be made, so that the other side is not dragged to a distant court it never agreed to.

Civil ProcedureDelhi High Court

Harish Kumar vs. Yatender Arora and Ors

The Court held that the only question was whether such a petition could be heard at all. An order under Order XXXIX Rule 10 CPC can be appealed under Order XLIII Rule 1(r) CPC, and in a commercial case that appeal goes to the Commercial Appellate Division under Section 13(1A) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015. Relying on Supreme Court rulings including Virudhunagar Hindu Nadargal Dharma Paribalana Sabai and P. Suresh v. D. Kalaivani, the Court said that where the CPC itself gives a right of appeal, it acts as a "near total bar" on using Article 227, which cannot be used to get around the appeal route or its time limit. As no exceptional circumstance was shown, the petition was dismissed at the outset as not maintainable, without any view on the merits, and the tenant was left free to pursue any other remedy available in law.

Decided 17 Nov 2026Read case
Civil ProcedureDelhi High Court

VLCC Personal Care Limited vs. Sudhir Solvent Private Limited

The Court agreed with VLCC that the February 2022 WhatsApp service was defective, because it carried only a photo of the summons without the plaint, as Order V Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) requires. But it held that the July 2022 email service was valid, since it was sent to the company's MCA-registered email address and to four other addresses listed in the suit papers, and VLCC showed nothing to prove it could not access them. A company must keep access to the email address it registers with the MCA, and must update it if it changes. Following the Supreme Court's ruling in SCG Contracts India, the 120-day limit under Order VIII Rule 1 CPC for commercial suits is strict, and VLCC's 120 days ran out on 20 November 2022, before it moved the court on 22 November 2022. The petition was dismissed and VLCC lost its right to file a written statement.

Decided 17 Nov 2026Read case
Civil ProcedureDelhi High Court

Ms. Mili Singh vs. M/s. Celebrations

The High Court relied on Supreme Court rulings holding that where a defendant raises genuine triable issues (disputes that need a proper trial with evidence), "leave to defend" should ordinarily be unconditional, and conditions must not be so harsh that they shut out a real defence. Her bank records showed only Rs. 4,44,500 coming from the plaintiff, with no proof of the claimed cash payments. She had also been acquitted in the cheque bounce case under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, where the court found nothing to show she ran any investment business and noted two different handwritings on the cheque. The Court held these were serious disputes, not bare denials, set aside the 50% deposit condition and the decree, and sent the suit back for a full trial, with parties to appear before the Saket Courts on 26 November 2026.

Decided 17 Nov 2026Read case
Civil ProcedureSupreme Court of India

Yusuf v. Vigyapan Loke Delhi Advertising C.G.H.S. Ltd.

The Supreme Court held balance-sheet entries can constitute a written acknowledgment of liability under Section 18 of the Limitation Act, reviving the limitation period with each entry: the acknowledgment needn't name the creditor specifically, only indicate a subsisting debt relationship. It held courts shouldn't dig into the depths of evidence at the plaint-rejection stage to conclusively rule out liability, since that's a matter for trial. The suit was revived.

Decided 6 Nov 2026Read case
Civil ProcedureSupreme Court of India

G. Pazhanivel v. S. Thilagavathy

The Supreme Court held a plaint can indeed be rejected even before formal registration, but found both lower courts erred on the merits: they fixated only on the sale deed lacking a re-sale clause, ignored other averments (the claimed security arrangement, continued possession), and effectively predicted the plaintiff would lose at trial rather than asking whether the plaint disclosed any cause of action at all. Since a meaningful reading did disclose a cause of action, dismissal without trial was improper. The Court restored the plaint and directed that pre-registration rejections must now be formally logged for future reference.

Decided 5 Nov 2026Read case
Civil ProcedureDelhi High Court

Economic Transport Organisation vs. M/s New India Assurance Co. Ltd. & Anr.

The National Commission had repeatedly asked for dissolution documents and partner details before ruling no apportionment was needed before execution. The High Court held its Article 227 power is narrow: it can't re-examine facts or act as an appellate court, and one of the two challenged orders was appealable only to the Supreme Court. Once a decree is final, a judgment-debtor can't use execution to reopen the liability the decree fixed. The petition was dismissed.

Decided 30 Oct 2026Read case
Balar Marketing Private Limited vs. Samsubramani…