Ms. Mili Singh vs. M/s. Celebrations
Background
M/s Celebrations, a shop run by Sumit Batra, filed a summary suit (a fast-track suit for recovering money, under Order XXXVII of the Code of Civil Procedure) to recover Rs. 7,50,000 from Mili Singh, a widow. He claimed she took the money promising 10% monthly returns from stock market investments, and that her cheque for the amount bounced. She said she had only taken a friendly loan of Rs. 1,44,500, had given blank signed cheques as security, and that a further Rs. 3,00,000 put into her account was withdrawn by his own employee. The trial court allowed her to defend only if she deposited 50% of the principal amount, and when she could not pay, it decreed the suit against her.
Decision Breakdown
The High Court relied on Supreme Court rulings holding that where a defendant raises genuine triable issues (disputes that need a proper trial with evidence), "leave to defend" should ordinarily be unconditional, and conditions must not be so harsh that they shut out a real defence. Her bank records showed only Rs. 4,44,500 coming from the plaintiff, with no proof of the claimed cash payments. She had also been acquitted in the cheque bounce case under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, where the court found nothing to show she ran any investment business and noted two different handwritings on the cheque. The Court held these were serious disputes, not bare denials, set aside the 50% deposit condition and the decree, and sent the suit back for a full trial, with parties to appear before the Saket Courts on 26 November 2026.
Lesson Learnt
In a summary suit for money, a defendant who raises a genuine defence should usually be allowed to contest the case without first paying a large sum. A court should not impose a deposit condition that a person with a real defence cannot afford, since that shuts them out of the trial.