Chetan Sabharwal v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle 28(1), New Delhi
Background
A taxpayer sold shares for Rs. 255 crore in 2007 and his original assessments were accepted after scrutiny. Years later, an Investigation Unit found the shares had been sold far above real value and that sale proceeds were used to claim a tax exemption. The department reopened the case more than four years later; the taxpayer challenged the reopening.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court upheld the reopening, holding a tax officer's "reason to believe" income escaped assessment requires only credible material for reasonable suspicion, not proof beyond doubt. The Investigation Report was new, tangible material not before the officer originally, validly triggering reopening. The Court also rejected the "change of opinion" argument since the original assessment never actually engaged with the valuation issue.
Lesson Learnt
An assessment being accepted once does not make it permanently immune from reopening: if authorities later uncover genuinely new, concrete information, they can lawfully reassess within statutory time limits.