Damodar Valley Corporation v. Maithan Alloys Limited & Ors.
Background
The Appellate Tribunal for Electricity had upheld (in 2019) the tariff fixed for Damodar Valley Corporation (DVC) for 2009-2014, following a binding 2018 Supreme Court precedent that allowed DVC to factor its "Sinking Fund" (set aside to redeem bonds) into tariff as an expense alongside depreciation. Years later, one consumer's review petition against that 2019 order was allowed in 2024, over five years after it was filed, with the Tribunal now holding that allowing both depreciation and the Sinking Fund amounted to an impermissible "double benefit," a point it claimed the Supreme Court's earlier decision had overlooked.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court set aside the Tribunal's 2024 review order and restored its original 2019 order, calling the review "clearly illegal, totally misplaced and blatantly in breach of the principles of judicial discipline" and a violation of Article 141 (which binds all courts to Supreme Court precedent). After re-examining its own 2018 decision, the Court confirmed that allowing both depreciation and the Sinking Fund as tariff expenses was specifically considered and upheld: there was no overlooked "double benefit" issue, and a tribunal cannot use review powers to effectively re-argue a settled legal question it disagrees with. The Court imposed costs of Rs. 2,00,000 on the reviewing consumer and Rs. 1,50,000 on a public-sector intervenor for pursuing this abuse of process for over five years.
Lesson Learnt
A tribunal's power of review is meant only to correct a genuine, self-evident error apparent on the record, not to reopen and relitigate a legal question already settled by a binding higher-court precedent; attempting to do so, especially after a long delay, can draw heavy costs for abuse of process.