Damodar Valley Corporation v. Maithan Alloys Limited & Ors.

Civil Appeal · 2026 INSC 1178Decided 30 Oct 2026
Civil Appeal No. 11106 of 2024
Justice J.B. Pardiwala · Justice K. Vinod Chandran

Background

The Appellate Tribunal for Electricity had upheld (in 2019) the tariff fixed for Damodar Valley Corporation (DVC) for 2009-2014, following a binding 2018 Supreme Court precedent that allowed DVC to factor its "Sinking Fund" (set aside to redeem bonds) into tariff as an expense alongside depreciation. Years later, one consumer's review petition against that 2019 order was allowed in 2024, over five years after it was filed, with the Tribunal now holding that allowing both depreciation and the Sinking Fund amounted to an impermissible "double benefit," a point it claimed the Supreme Court's earlier decision had overlooked.

Decision Breakdown

The Supreme Court set aside the Tribunal's 2024 review order and restored its original 2019 order, calling the review "clearly illegal, totally misplaced and blatantly in breach of the principles of judicial discipline" and a violation of Article 141 (which binds all courts to Supreme Court precedent). After re-examining its own 2018 decision, the Court confirmed that allowing both depreciation and the Sinking Fund as tariff expenses was specifically considered and upheld: there was no overlooked "double benefit" issue, and a tribunal cannot use review powers to effectively re-argue a settled legal question it disagrees with. The Court imposed costs of Rs. 2,00,000 on the reviewing consumer and Rs. 1,50,000 on a public-sector intervenor for pursuing this abuse of process for over five years.

Lesson Learnt

A tribunal's power of review is meant only to correct a genuine, self-evident error apparent on the record, not to reopen and relitigate a legal question already settled by a binding higher-court precedent; attempting to do so, especially after a long delay, can draw heavy costs for abuse of process.

Electricity & Energy LawSupreme Court of India

Power Grid Corporation of India Ltd. v. TANGEDCO

The Supreme Court allowed PGCIL's appeals, set aside both APTEL orders, and restored CERC's order. It held that the LILOs were a permanent, agreed part of the transmission plan approved in Standing Committee meetings (binding under Section 29(4) of the Electricity Act, 2003) and that the generator's power was in fact routed through them: the generator had itself admitted using the pooling station to evacuate power. Since transmission was never held up, the special rule for fixing the operation date when a line cannot be used because of another party's delay (Regulation 4(3)(ii) of the 2014 Tariff Regulations) did not apply, and CERC had rightly accepted the dates based on trial-operation and safety certificates. Relying on its earlier ruling in PGCIL v. Madhya Pradesh Power Transmission Co. (2025), the Court held the generator, which delayed its own dedicated line, must bear the LILO transmission charges from January 2015 to 27 October 2016.

Decided 18 Nov 2026Read case
Electricity & Energy LawSupreme Court of India

Rekha v. Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Ltd.

The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, set aside the High Court's 10 May 2024 judgment and restored the trial court's award. It held that a civil case is decided on "preponderance of probability" (which version is more likely true, on the evidence), not on a judge's personal doubt or suspicion. The power company's only witness admitted he had not seen the incident, was not even on duty that day, and that maintaining the lines was the company's responsibility, while Rekha's evidence stood unshaken in cross-examination. An appeal court may overturn a trial court's findings of fact only for real defects such as misreading of evidence or reliance on inadmissible evidence, not because of delay in complaining, minor inconsistencies, or a "fault-finding expedition." The Court added that the case attracts the strict liability of the electricity company.

Decided 16 Nov 2026Read case
Electricity & Energy LawSupreme Court of India

State of Himachal Pradesh v. Union of India and Others

This judgment is the final execution order closing the decree. The Court accepted the computed figure that Himachal Pradesh is owed 13,066 million units of energy arrears since 1966-67, while itself owing Rs. 420.77 crore in capital costs. It rejected Punjab's objections as attempts to relitigate matters already settled in 2011, extended the repayment period to 20 years as a concession, and ordered a cashless settlement converting Himachal Pradesh's capital liability into energy units to be set off against the arrears.

Decided 6 Nov 2026Read case
Electricity & Energy LawDelhi High Court

NTPC Ltd. vs. South Delhi Municipal Corporation & Ors.

The Court held that using one's own electricity to run machinery is still "consumption," not generation, and falls within the taxable category; the bye-law only clarified liability, not expanded it. On double taxation, the tax on units supplied to consumers and on self-consumed units were separate, non-overlapping charges. On delay, since the liability accrued automatically each month by law and NTPC never filed required returns, it couldn't rely on the Corporation's delay to escape liability. The petition was dismissed, though NTPC could separately dispute the exact calculated amount.

Decided 27 Oct 2026Read case
Electricity & Energy LawSupreme Court of India

Dakshin Gujarat Vij Company Limited & Anr. v. Vaibhav Metal Crusher (with connected appeal)

The Supreme Court held that even in theft cases, since the Act provides no separate assessment procedure, the amount needed for restoring supply must use the same procedure as ordinary unauthorized-use cases, giving consumers a provisional assessment, a chance to object, and a right of appeal. However, this process is final only for restoring the connection; it doesn't override the Special Court's separate power to finally determine civil liability once a criminal theft complaint is filed, with any excess deposit refundable later.

Decided 26 Oct 2026Read case
Electricity & Energy LawDelhi High Court

Radhey Shyam Gupta vs. Tata Power Delhi Distribution Limited

Both the trial court and the first appellate court had dismissed the suit, holding that the Electricity Act, 2003 gives exclusive jurisdiction over such compensation disputes to statutory bodies like the District Magistrate or Commissioner of Police rather than to civil courts, and that the plaintiff had failed to prove any actual monetary loss to justify the damages claimed. The High Court agreed on both points: even though the electricity company had indeed skipped the legally required step of getting the landowner's consent or, failing that, permission from the District Magistrate/Police Commissioner before laying its lines, the law still channels any compensation dispute exclusively to those statutory authorities, not the civil courts. Separately, the plaintiff had given no real evidence (such as how the property's value dropped, or how Rs. 50,000/month was calculated) to support his damages claim. Since no genuine "substantial question of law" was raised, the Regular Second Appeal was dismissed.

Decided 18 Sept 2026Read case