Rekha v. Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Ltd.
Background
Rekha, then a minor, said that on 15 July 2011 she was badly burnt when she tried to push away a sagging 11 KV electricity line hanging only 3-4 feet above the ground in her village in Rajasthan; her right hand later had to be amputated and she was left permanently disabled. She sued the state power distribution company (JVVNL), and the trial court awarded her Rs. 8,70,000 compensation with 6% interest. The Rajasthan High Court reversed this, calling her story "unbelievable", reasoning that nobody could survive touching an 11 KV line, that she reported the incident to police late, and that her witnesses were inconsistent.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, set aside the High Court's 10 May 2024 judgment and restored the trial court's award. It held that a civil case is decided on "preponderance of probability" (which version is more likely true, on the evidence), not on a judge's personal doubt or suspicion. The power company's only witness admitted he had not seen the incident, was not even on duty that day, and that maintaining the lines was the company's responsibility, while Rekha's evidence stood unshaken in cross-examination. An appeal court may overturn a trial court's findings of fact only for real defects such as misreading of evidence or reliance on inadmissible evidence, not because of delay in complaining, minor inconsistencies, or a "fault-finding expedition." The Court added that the case attracts the strict liability of the electricity company.
Lesson Learnt
Electricity companies are strictly responsible for injuries caused by poorly maintained, sagging live wires, and a victim's claim cannot be thrown out simply because a judge finds the story surprising. In civil cases, courts must decide on the evidence actually led: a delay in reporting or small inconsistencies do not by themselves destroy an otherwise credible claim.