State of Himachal Pradesh v. Union of India and Others
Background
Himachal Pradesh sued in 1996 for a share of power from major hydro projects built partly on land now within the state but whose power had gone to other states. A 2011 decree gave Himachal Pradesh 7.19% of Punjab's share and directed computation of what was actually owed, a process that remained disputed for over a decade.
Decision Breakdown
This judgment is the final execution order closing the decree. The Court accepted the computed figure that Himachal Pradesh is owed 13,066 million units of energy arrears since 1966-67, while itself owing Rs. 420.77 crore in capital costs. It rejected Punjab's objections as attempts to relitigate matters already settled in 2011, extended the repayment period to 20 years as a concession, and ordered a cashless settlement converting Himachal Pradesh's capital liability into energy units to be set off against the arrears.
Lesson Learnt
Even after a decree finally settles legal entitlement, converting it into actual compensation can take many more years of further litigation over computation: courts will firmly shut down attempts to use execution proceedings to reopen already-decided issues.