NTPC Ltd. vs. South Delhi Municipal Corporation & Ors.
Background
NTPC's Badarpur Thermal Power Station used part of its generated electricity for its own operations ("auxiliary consumption"). The South Delhi Municipal Corporation demanded nearly Rs. 197 crore in municipal electricity tax on this self-used electricity for 2006-2018. NTPC argued the taxing bye-law exceeded the parent Act, that this amounted to double taxation, and that the demand was too old.
Decision Breakdown
The Court held that using one's own electricity to run machinery is still "consumption," not generation, and falls within the taxable category; the bye-law only clarified liability, not expanded it. On double taxation, the tax on units supplied to consumers and on self-consumed units were separate, non-overlapping charges. On delay, since the liability accrued automatically each month by law and NTPC never filed required returns, it couldn't rely on the Corporation's delay to escape liability. The petition was dismissed, though NTPC could separately dispute the exact calculated amount.
Lesson Learnt
A tax liability that automatically accrues under law each month doesn't expire just because the authority was slow to demand it, and using something yourself, rather than selling it, can still count as "consuming" it for tax purposes.