In Re: Phalodi Accident v. National Highways Authority of India
Background
This order does not decide the main suo motu case on highway safety. After fatal road accidents at Phalodi, Rajasthan and elsewhere, the Supreme Court took up highway safety on its own and, on 13 April 2026, ordered authorities to remove unauthorised structures (such as dhabas, eateries and commercial buildings) from the "Right of Way" (the land legally reserved for a National Highway). Acting on this, NHAI issued removal notices, and many people, mostly in Gujarat districts such as Valsad and Navsari, including hotel and petrol-pump owners, came to the Court saying the structures stood on their own private land, that NHAI's measurements were wrong, or that their land had never been acquired or paid for.
Decision Breakdown
This is not a final judgment: it clarifies earlier directions in a case that is still pending. The Court clarified that its 13 April 2026 directions addressed the general problem of highway encroachments and did not decide whether any particular building was an encroachment. Authorities must still follow the procedure in Section 26 of the Control of National Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002 (notice, a chance to object, and consideration of the objection) and cannot cite the Court's order as a shortcut around the law. Since ownership, boundary and acquisition disputes need examination of revenue records and surveys, the Court sent the applicants to their respective High Courts and expressed no view on the merits. Until those cases are decided, no demolition or coercive action may be taken on the disputed structures, but this protection creates no rights in the applicants' favour and permits no new construction; the original directions otherwise remain in force.
Lesson Learnt
Even a court-ordered drive against encroachments does not allow officials to demolish a property without first following the legal process of notice and hearing. A person who believes their land is wrongly labelled as an encroachment can seek protection and have their ownership claim examined by the High Court.