U.P. Ground Water Department Non Gazetted Employee Association v. Chief Secretary
Background
Many Uttar Pradesh government employees in departments such as Public Works, Irrigation and Ground Water started in the late 1970s and 1980s as "work-charged" (project-based), daily-wage or muster-roll workers and were regularised years later. The State refused to count their pre-regularisation service towards pension. In Prem Singh v. State of U.P. (2019), the Supreme Court held that such work-charged service must count as qualifying service for pension; the State's review failed, but it then passed the Validation Act, 2021 and, while this case was being heard, the Validation Act, 2025, both retrospective from 1961, redefining pension eligibility (for example by limiting it to "substantive appointees") and declaring past denials of pension valid "notwithstanding" any court judgment.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court declared both the 2021 and 2025 Validation Acts unconstitutional. It held that a legislature may cure the defect a court has identified, but cannot simply put the same exclusion in "a new statutory dress" and declare a final judgment ineffective; these Acts changed the label but kept the very discrimination Prem Singh had struck down. It rejected the State's plea of a heavy financial burden, noting that money found for park beautification cannot rank above legal obligations owed to employees. It directed that eligible retirees may apply with their service details and the authority must decide within six months (with a hearing and reasoned order before any rejection), with arrears limited to three years as in Prem Singh, except for heirs of employees who died before Prem Singh was decided; late payment attracts 9% simple interest. The benefits apply to all eligible employees whether or not they belong to the petitioning association, and in the pending contempt cases the State was given a final six months to pay what is due under Prem Singh.
Lesson Learnt
Years of real service given to the government before regularisation cannot be wiped out for pension purposes just by rewording the law; a government cannot use legislation to undo a final court judgment without actually fixing the legal flaw. The Court also advised that when an association files a case for its members, it should attach a list of those members.