Ku. Kiran Bhujade v. Sudhir Shikshan Sanstha
Background
An assistant teacher at a Nagpur school, appointed in 2009, complained in 2021 to the Education Minister and officials that the school's Secretary, Rajesh Masurkar, had deliberately left her name off the list of staff eligible for government grant-in-aid salary; an official committee agreed and ordered her name to be included. Soon after, the management (a society run largely by the Masurkar family) charged her with misconduct. In the inquiry, Rajesh Masurkar issued the charge-sheet, acted as presenting officer, was the sole witness on 11 of 20 charges and signed her termination, while his real brother, Prakash Masurkar, chaired the inquiry committee. She was terminated in February 2022; the School Tribunal ordered her reinstatement with full back wages, but the Bombay High Court (Nagpur Bench) restored the termination in 2025.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, set aside the High Court judgment and restored the Tribunal's order of reinstatement with continuity of service and full back wages. It held that the test is not whether actual bias is proved but whether a fair-minded person would see a "reasonable likelihood of bias", and that close family ties can disqualify an adjudicator. Here there was a "total familial capture" of the inquiry: the complainant, chief witness and prosecutor gave evidence before his own brother as judge, which breaks the rule that no one should be a judge in their own cause and violates Article 14. Following procedures such as hearings and cross-examination cannot cure such bias, the "doctrine of necessity" did not apply because two unrelated committee members were available, and she had not waived her objection since she raised it at every stage. The Court also directed the Education Officer to consider absorbing her in another fully government-aided school.
Lesson Learnt
A disciplinary inquiry must not only be fair but also look fair; if the person accusing you, the main witness and the judge are close family members, the whole inquiry can be struck down even without proof of actual bias. Employees should raise objections to a biased inquiry panel early and keep raising them.