Prithviraj S. Singh (Deceased) Through LRs v. Secretary, School Education Department, State of Maharashtra
Background
Two clerks of a Mumbai private school were charged with misappropriation of money; they boycotted the inquiry in protest over a committee member, the inquiry went ahead without them, and they were terminated without being given the inquiry reports. When they appealed to the School Tribunal, the Bombay High Court passed a consent order in March 2005 allowing the school to lead evidence before the Tribunal to prove the charges. The school never did, yet the Tribunal dismissed the clerks' appeals in 2006. Their writ petitions to the High Court did not raise this failure and instead only claimed the same lighter treatment given to the headmaster, and were dismissed in 2016.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court noted that a party must plead its case, and the clerks' arguments on the merits went beyond what their writ petitions said, so strictly the appeal could have been dismissed. But it found it a matter of serious concern that the school ignored the High Court's consent order: there was effectively no evidence before the Tribunal to prove the charges, and the non-supply of inquiry reports was itself a serious flaw. Applying the principle that an action contrary to an express judicial order is a nullity, and using its special power under Article 142 of the Constitution (to do complete justice), the Court directed the school to pay each appellant (the heirs in the case of the deceased clerk) Rs. 10,00,000 as lump-sum compensation for wrongful termination within three months, as full and final settlement, with 12% annual interest if paid late.
Lesson Learnt
How a case is drafted matters greatly: courts generally decide only what is actually pleaded, and a strong case can be weakened by poor pleadings. Still, the Supreme Court can step in to prevent clear injustice, especially where a party has ignored a court order.