M/s R.B. Saxena and Sons vs. East Delhi Municipal Corporation & Ors. and connected matters
Background
Five contractors supplied auto-tipper vehicles with staff to lift garbage and drain silt in East Delhi, under a 2012 tender issued by the unified MCD. MCD's notified rates paid workers 25% more for work in "foul conditions" (Rs. 297 a day instead of Rs. 238). After MCD was split into three corporations, East Delhi Municipal Corporation (EDMC) issued work orders that left out the foul condition clause, but still paid the higher rate until February 2016. From March 2016, without any notice, EDMC began deducting 25% from their bills, and in February 2018 told them it was recovering "excess payments" flagged by audit and vigilance.
Decision Breakdown
The Court found that EDMC itself admitted the tender was for foul condition work at the Rs. 297 rate, and its own Executive Engineer had told the auditors there was no irregularity. It held that leaving the clause out of the work orders was a clerical mistake, that the other two corporations formed from the same tender kept paying the higher rate, and that EDMC gave no show cause notice before deducting. This made the deductions arbitrary and in breach of Article 14 of the Constitution (the right to equal and fair treatment by the State). The Court rejected the objection of delay, noting one contractor had gone to court repeatedly since 2016, the others had filed within time of the February 2018 demand, and the Supreme Court's COVID-period limitation extension covered the 2021 petition. It also held that a writ petition (a direct petition to the High Court against a State body) can be heard in a contract dispute where the State acts arbitrarily and the facts are admitted. EDMC's recovery letters were set aside and it was directed to refund all deducted amounts with 8% annual interest.
Lesson Learnt
Government bodies must act fairly even in contract matters. They cannot cut payments they have been making for years, without notice and without a reason, merely because an audit raised an objection. Where the facts are admitted, a contractor can seek relief directly from the High Court instead of filing a civil suit.