Kasturi Rajan & Ors. vs. Vatsala Vescio & Ors.
Background
A property dispute running since 2008 saw the plaintiff withdraw a request to drop two defendants, and the trial court also advanced the hearing date given the plaintiff's advanced age. The remaining defendants challenged both decisions.
Decision Breakdown
The Court held the original request was conditional, not an irreversible abandonment, and under Supreme Court precedent (Rajendra Prasad Gupta), a court's inherent power allows withdrawing even a withdrawal request unless the law expressly forbids it. It upheld advancing the hearing date given the 16-year pendency and the plaintiff's age.
Lesson Learnt
Not every procedural request to drop a party is an irreversible "abandonment": courts look at what the request actually says and retain inherent power to allow its withdrawal, particularly in old, long-pending cases.