LTU Lufttransport Unternehmen GmbH (now merged into Air Berlin PLC & Co. Luftverkehrs KG) vs. Airports Authority of India
Background
A German airline overpaid the Airports Authority of India (AAI) by mistakenly remitting an amount in US dollars instead of rupees. AAI acknowledged the debt in writing, refunded only part, leaving about Rs. 68.24 lakh unpaid for three years. The trial court agreed the airline was owed the money but dismissed the suit as time-barred due to a short delay in fixing curable paperwork defects after filing.
Decision Breakdown
The High Court agreed the airline had proved entitlement, since AAI's own letter admitted the debt. On timing, the plaint was first presented two days before the deadline but sent back for curable defects (missing vakalatnama, court-fee issues) fixed about a week later. The Court held such defects don't make the original filing "non-existent": the filing date for limitation is the day first presented, not when defects were cured. The dismissal was overturned and Rs. 68.24 lakh plus 6% interest awarded.
Lesson Learnt
If you file within the deadline but the registry sends it back for minor paperwork fixes, your filing date for limitation purposes is still the original presentation date.