Manoj Kumar (Prop. M K Steel Traders) vs. Additional Commissioner, Central GST & Anr. and connected matters
Background
A GST investigation into fake-invoice ITC claims accused the petitioner of distributing fake invoices for a commission, resulting in two tax demand orders (Rs. 6.1 lakh and Rs. 2.93 crore), which he challenged directly in the High Court as too vague and improperly penalized.
Decision Breakdown
The Court held a statutory appeal is the proper route except in limited situations (clear lack of jurisdiction or a wholly unreasoned notice). The first notice ran to nearly 80 pages with detailed allegations, so wasn't legally deficient for being joint. The penalty question was left for the appellate tax authority to decide. Both petitions were dismissed or relegated to appeal.
Lesson Learnt
Having a legal objection to a tax notice doesn't let you skip the regular appeal process: courts generally insist on the statutory appeal first, reserving writ intervention for genuinely exceptional defects.