M/s. Balaji Formalin Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. v. Union of India & Anr.

Writ Petition (Civil) · 2026 INSC 1009Decided 18 Sept 2026
W.P.(C) No. 893 of 2019 with W.P.(C) No. 1059 of 2019 and Civil Appeal No. 13008 of 2026
Justice J.B. Pardiwala · Justice K. Vinod Chandran

Background

After a 1991 hooch tragedy in Mumbai in which about 93 people died from consuming liquor spiked with methanol, Maharashtra amended its Poisons Rules in 2011 to insert Rules 18A and 18B, requiring anyone buying methanol (other than for drug manufacture) to hold a licence and to have the methanol mixed with a bitterant/colourant, with unlicensed possession subject to confiscation. Industrial users of methanol, needed to make formaldehyde, disinfectants, paints, resins, and other legitimate products, challenged the rules as arbitrary and disproportionate, since adding the denaturant made their methanol commercially unusable, while methanol was already tightly regulated as a hazardous substance under separate Petroleum Rules. The Bombay High Court had upheld the rules in one of the connected matters, prompting these petitions/appeal to the Supreme Court.

Decision Breakdown

The Court held that subordinate legislation must meet the same constitutional tests as primary legislation, including proportionality: a legitimate aim, suitability of the measure to achieve it, absence of a less restrictive alternative, and proportionate burden versus benefit. Applying this test, it found that mandatory denaturing of methanol sold to non-drug manufacturers did nothing to stop diversion of methanol into illicit liquor (since the tragedy arose from pilferage/diversion, not lawful industrial sales), that existing safeguards in the Poisons Rules (licensing, stock registers, inspections) if properly enforced were a less restrictive alternative, and that the substantial, continuing commercial burden on industry (loss of yield, equipment damage, health hazards from improper evaporation) was disproportionate to a merely speculative benefit, especially since the State could not show what it had done between 1991 and 2011, and the rules had already been stayed for about 14 years. The Court therefore struck down Rules 18A and 18B as violative of Articles 14 and 19(1)(g), while also making broader observations (citing repeated hooch tragedies even in "dry" states like Gujarat) that blanket restrictive/prohibition-style measures often fail and that better enforcement of existing transport/storage safeguards is the real solution.

Lesson Learnt

A regulation restricting a lawful industry to address a public-safety problem must actually be shown to solve that problem and must be the least restrictive way of doing so. Courts will strike down rules that impose serious, ongoing commercial burdens for only a speculative or unproven safety benefit, particularly when the government cannot show it tried better enforcement of existing safeguards first.

Constitutional LawSupreme Court of India

The Chairman, National Book Trust, India and Another v. A.R. Abdul Gaffar and Others

The Supreme Court applied the cumulative test from Ajay Hasia and Pradeep Kumar Biswas, finding decisive government control: the Chairman is appointed by and serves at the Government's pleasure, Ministry representatives sit on its governing bodies, its finances run through a Government-prescribed audit framework, and rule changes require Government approval. The Trust's independent revenue didn't displace this, since the inquiry is cumulative, not factor-by-factor. The Court clarified that State status under Article 12 only triggers fundamental-rights obligations, not civil-servant status for employees.

Decided 6 Nov 2026Read case
Constitutional LawSupreme Court of India

Surendra Manjhi & Anr. v. Union of India & Ors. (with connected petition)

Rather than disposing of the case, the Court issued sweeping directions to fix the systemic delays: a uniform nationwide Standard Operating Procedure to be implemented within six months, release certificates within 24 hours of identification, financial assistance within seven days of release, individual rehabilitation plans within 90 days, designated nodal officers for inter-state coordination, functioning Vigilance Committees, a digital monitoring portal, and dedicated grievance officers. It held that "rehabilitation delayed may, in substance, amount to rehabilitation denied," and kept the case pending for continued monitoring, listing it again after seven months.

Decided 2 Nov 2026Read case
Constitutional LawSupreme Court of India

Srinivasa T. & Ors. v. The State of Karnataka and Ors. Etc. Etc. (with connected appeals)

The Supreme Court held the validation Act unconstitutional, ruling a legislature can retrospectively cure a legal defect a court identified, but cannot nullify or override a specific final judgment between specific parties, that violates the separation of powers. Since the recruitment was invalidated for substantive corruption, not a mere procedural defect, there was no "defect" left to cure; the Act simply tried to legislatively overturn binding judgments. As relief, the Court directed fresh recruitment for the vacant posts, with a one-time age relaxation for untainted earlier candidates, but no back wages or retrospective seniority for anyone reselected.

Decided 29 Oct 2026Read case
Constitutional LawSupreme Court of India

The Secretary to Government v. Sameer Ahamed N. and Others

The Supreme Court upheld the High Court, dismissing the state's appeal. It held that membership in a specific notified Muslim community is a matter of historical or social lineage, not something automatically acquired by conversion: a person's prior caste-based disadvantage in the Hindu social order cannot be "carried forward" into an unrelated post-conversion community classification. It also held the state could not delegate this core statutory determination to private religious bodies, since such public-law determinations must remain with accountable government authority.

Decided 15 Oct 2026Read case
Constitutional LawSupreme Court of India

Federation of Medical and Sales Representatives Associations of India & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors.

This is an interim order, not a final judgment. The Court recorded the Union of India's proposal to set up a fresh three-member Committee to examine the issue and recommend a regulatory or statutory framework. It directed the Union to constitute the Committee within two weeks, directed the Committee to consult the petitioners, intervenors and other stakeholders and report within two months of its first meeting, and asked the Union to file a compliance affidavit. Citing the separation of powers, the Court declined to decide for itself whether the Code should become law, and listed the matter on 29 January 2027.

Decided 8 Oct 2026Read case
Constitutional LawDelhi High Court

Sirajuddin Qureshi & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors.

The Court held that a bank's fear that the petitioners might flee, or its unresolved financial claim, cannot by itself justify keeping an LOC alive indefinitely, especially where the petitioners' bail conditions impose no travel curbs and their track record shows no misuse. It quashed the LOCs issued at the banks' instance, while leaving the LOCs issued at CBI's instance to be addressed through an application before the trial court (since those criminal proceedings are still pending there).

Decided 7 Oct 2026Read case
M/s. Balaji Formalin Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. v. Union of India &…