M/s. Lakshmi Sugar Mills Co. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Delhi-II
Background
A sugar manufacturer's tax auditor flagged unpaid excise duty on closing stock kept in a bonded warehouse, which the company had never charged to its Profit and Loss Account. The Assessing Officer added this amount back to taxable income under Section 43B. The CIT (Appeals) and Tribunal ruled for the company, but the Delhi High Court reversed, wrongly finding the goods had been "admittedly removed" from the factory.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court restored the rulings favouring the company, finding the High Court's factual premise wrong: the stock had never actually left the bonded warehouse. Section 43B only disallows an amount the taxpayer actually claimed as a deductible expense in its books; since the company never routed this unpaid duty through its Profit and Loss Account, there was nothing to disallow. A tax auditor's advisory remark alone, without an actual claimed deduction, cannot trigger a Section 43B addition.
Lesson Learnt
A business cannot be taxed on a deduction it never actually claimed: a mere observation in a tax audit report that a duty is "payable" is not, by itself, grounds for the tax department to add that sum back to taxable income.