M/S. Sikka Motors Pvt Ltd vs. Union of India & Anr.
Background
Sikka Motors, a Hyundai dealership, was accused of wrongly claiming input tax credit for 2019-20. The tax department issued a Show Cause Notice and then an order. The dealership argued the notice was actually made available on the GST portal only on 08.08.2024, after the legal deadline of 31.05.2024, making the proceeding invalid.
Decision Breakdown
The Court found an earlier version of the notice existed only on the department's internal system, was never confirmed on the portal, and carried no official reference number, meaning it was never actually "issued." The department's claim of a mere "technical glitch" was rejected: it had alternative ways (post, email) to serve the notice on time but didn't use them. Since the real notice only took effect on 08.08.2024, both the notice and the resulting order were time-barred and struck down.
Lesson Learnt
A government tax demand must follow its own statutory deadlines; an authority's internal administrative mistake cannot be used to extend a legal deadline at the taxpayer's expense.