Om Shankar Metal (through its Proprietor Mr. Sidhant Sharma) vs. Assistant Commissioner Mohan Co-operative Industrial Estate Division Delhi East Delhi, CBIC

Writ Petition (Civil) · 2026:DHC:8917-DBDecided 9 Oct 2026New Delhi Bench
W.P.(C) 15708/2025CNR: DLHC010779382025
Justice Anil Kshetarpal · Justice Bharat Parashar

Background

A sole-proprietorship metal trading firm was issued an ex-parte GST demand order (under Section 74 of the CGST Act) alleging wrongful input tax credit claims, after a departmental audit. The firm challenged the order, arguing it was never actually given a personal hearing before the order was passed, saying the department's hearing notices were sent to the wrong email address.

Decision Breakdown

The Court held the petition was maintainable despite an available statutory appeal, since an alleged denial of a fair hearing is a recognised exception that justifies approaching the writ court directly. However, it found that which email address was actually the firm's correct, registered one was a genuinely disputed question of fact that could not be properly resolved in writ proceedings and should instead go to the Appellate Authority, along with related disputes over penalty computation and interest calculation. The Court declined to decide the merits itself, relegated the firm to its statutory appeal under Section 107 of the CGST Act, and separately allowed it to seek exclusion of the litigation period from the appeal's limitation clock.

Lesson Learnt

A genuine complaint of being denied a fair hearing can get a writ petition heard even when a regular appeal route exists, but the High Court will still send genuinely disputed factual questions (like which email address was on file) to the proper appellate forum rather than decide them itself, while protecting the taxpayer's right to still file that appeal on time.

Tax & Customs LawSupreme Court of India

Arjun Flour Mills v. The State of Odisha Finance Department Secretary & Ors. (with numerous connected appeals)

The Court held the reference had become academic. The perceived conflict traced back to India Cement's premise that "royalty is a tax," a premise itself overruled by a 2024 Nine-Judge Bench ruling that royalty is contractual consideration, not a tax. With that conflict dissolved, the Court held the governing law remains its 1974 Constitution Bench ruling in S. Kodar v. State of Kerala, which held such a surcharge is simply an enhancement of the sales tax rate, within state competence. It also noted the underlying sales-tax regime has since been superseded by VAT and then GST, making the question largely of historical significance, and remitted the individual appeals to regular benches while leaving two narrower residual questions open.

Decided 4 Nov 2026Read case
Tax & Customs LawDelhi High Court

M/s Rajkalpana Travels Pvt. Ltd. vs. Commissioner, CGST, Delhi North Commissionerate

The Court held whether the right address was used is a factual dispute depending on registration records, exactly what the statutory appellate authority should examine, not a writ court. It sent the company to the appeal process instead of ruling on the merits.

Decided 28 Oct 2026Read case
Tax & Customs LawDelhi High Court

Gurvinder Saluja vs. New Delhi Municipal Council

The Court agreed a 2023 notice can't justify increases for years before it was issued, but found the full tangle of prior assessments too complex for a writ petition, relegating it to the statutory appeal authority. It ordered NDMC to first give a clear, itemized breakdown of the demand before any appeal clock starts running, barring coercive recovery meanwhile.

Decided 28 Oct 2026Read case
Tax & Customs LawDelhi High Court

Manoj Kumar (Prop. M K Steel Traders) vs. Additional Commissioner, Central GST & Anr. and connected matters

The Court held a statutory appeal is the proper route except in limited situations (clear lack of jurisdiction or a wholly unreasoned notice). The first notice ran to nearly 80 pages with detailed allegations, so wasn't legally deficient for being joint. The penalty question was left for the appellate tax authority to decide. Both petitions were dismissed or relegated to appeal.

Decided 28 Oct 2026Read case
Tax & Customs LawSupreme Court of India

Chetan Sabharwal v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle 28(1), New Delhi

The Supreme Court upheld the reopening, holding a tax officer's "reason to believe" income escaped assessment requires only credible material for reasonable suspicion, not proof beyond doubt. The Investigation Report was new, tangible material not before the officer originally, validly triggering reopening. The Court also rejected the "change of opinion" argument since the original assessment never actually engaged with the valuation issue.

Decided 28 Oct 2026Read case
Tax & Customs LawSupreme Court of India

Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Bhubaneshwar v. Orissa Mining Corporation Ltd. (with connected appeals)

The Supreme Court dismissed the Department's appeals, holding that a Section 143(2) notice is mandatory and a "sine qua non" for any reassessment: its omission is not a curable procedural irregularity. The Court rejected reliance on the provision deeming a notice validly served where the taxpayer participated without objecting: that fiction only cures defects in how or when a notice was served, not a case where no notice was issued at all. An assessee relying on its original return in response to a reopening notice does not relieve the Department of this duty.

Decided 28 Oct 2026Read case
Om Shankar Metal (through its Proprietor Mr. Sidhant…