Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Bhubaneshwar v. Orissa Mining Corporation Ltd. (with connected appeals)
Background
The Income Tax Department reopened completed assessments under Section 147 and issued reassessment notices, but never issued the mandatory Section 143(2) notice before completing the reassessment, only Section 142(1) notices seeking documents. The Tribunal and High Court both ruled this invalidated the entire reassessment; the Department appealed.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court dismissed the Department's appeals, holding that a Section 143(2) notice is mandatory and a "sine qua non" for any reassessment: its omission is not a curable procedural irregularity. The Court rejected reliance on the provision deeming a notice validly served where the taxpayer participated without objecting: that fiction only cures defects in how or when a notice was served, not a case where no notice was issued at all. An assessee relying on its original return in response to a reopening notice does not relieve the Department of this duty.
Lesson Learnt
If the tax department reopens your assessment, it must issue a formal notice under Section 143(2) before finalizing any reassessment: a hard, mandatory requirement that cannot be waived through cooperation or other correspondence.