Ritu Goel & Anr. vs. Kamlesh & Ors.

Regular First Appeal (Commercial) · 2026:DHC:7732-DBDecided 10 Sept 2026New Delhi Bench
RFA(COMM) 248/2026CNR: DLHC010164742026
Justice Prathiba M. Singh · Justice Vikas Mahajan

Background

A husband and wife (plaintiffs) paid over Rs. 1.4 crore in installments to the appellants (a family running a neighbouring shop) over several proposed property deals in Rohini, Delhi, none of which ever materialized into a valid transfer. When the deals fell through, the appellants issued four post-dated cheques worth Rs. 1.22 crore towards repayment, all of which bounced when the underlying bank accounts were blocked amid separate loan-default (SARFAESI) proceedings. The plaintiffs sued for recovery and won an ex-parte decree at trial, which two of the defendants appealed, claiming they were never properly served.

Decision Breakdown

The High Court dismissed the appeal, holding that the appellants had in fact been duly served, both had executed vakalatnamas (formal authorizations) for lawyers in the trial court, directly contradicting their claim of non-service. The Court found the appellants had knowingly participated in the fraudulent scheme, noting one appellant had personally signed receipts for large cash sums. The Court also rejected a separate application by one appellant to withdraw the appeal (in order to instead pursue a different legal remedy), calling it a "malafide attempt" to escape the decree, and imposed Rs. 10,000 costs. The Court further directed that a copy of the judgment be sent to the Income Tax Department to examine whether large cash payments violated tax law.

Lesson Learnt

Signing a vakalatnama (lawyer authorization) in a case is treated as proof you were properly notified of the proceedings: you cannot later claim you were never served. Courts also scrutinize attempts to withdraw an appeal at a late stage as a tactic to dodge an unfavourable decree.

Civil ProcedureSupreme Court of India

Yusuf v. Vigyapan Loke Delhi Advertising C.G.H.S. Ltd.

The Supreme Court held balance-sheet entries can constitute a written acknowledgment of liability under Section 18 of the Limitation Act, reviving the limitation period with each entry: the acknowledgment needn't name the creditor specifically, only indicate a subsisting debt relationship. It held courts shouldn't dig into the depths of evidence at the plaint-rejection stage to conclusively rule out liability, since that's a matter for trial. The suit was revived.

Decided 6 Nov 2026Read case
Civil ProcedureSupreme Court of India

G. Pazhanivel v. S. Thilagavathy

The Supreme Court held a plaint can indeed be rejected even before formal registration, but found both lower courts erred on the merits: they fixated only on the sale deed lacking a re-sale clause, ignored other averments (the claimed security arrangement, continued possession), and effectively predicted the plaintiff would lose at trial rather than asking whether the plaint disclosed any cause of action at all. Since a meaningful reading did disclose a cause of action, dismissal without trial was improper. The Court restored the plaint and directed that pre-registration rejections must now be formally logged for future reference.

Decided 5 Nov 2026Read case
Civil ProcedureDelhi High Court

Economic Transport Organisation vs. M/s New India Assurance Co. Ltd. & Anr.

The National Commission had repeatedly asked for dissolution documents and partner details before ruling no apportionment was needed before execution. The High Court held its Article 227 power is narrow: it can't re-examine facts or act as an appellate court, and one of the two challenged orders was appealable only to the Supreme Court. Once a decree is final, a judgment-debtor can't use execution to reopen the liability the decree fixed. The petition was dismissed.

Decided 30 Oct 2026Read case
Civil ProcedureDelhi High Court

LTU Lufttransport Unternehmen GmbH (now merged into Air Berlin PLC & Co. Luftverkehrs KG) vs. Airports Authority of India

The High Court agreed the airline had proved entitlement, since AAI's own letter admitted the debt. On timing, the plaint was first presented two days before the deadline but sent back for curable defects (missing vakalatnama, court-fee issues) fixed about a week later. The Court held such defects don't make the original filing "non-existent": the filing date for limitation is the day first presented, not when defects were cured. The dismissal was overturned and Rs. 68.24 lakh plus 6% interest awarded.

Decided 30 Oct 2026Read case
Civil ProcedureDelhi High Court

Jai Singh vs. Delhi Development Authority

On the main claim, the Court found DDA had no credible proof the contractor owed money for third-party rectification work and decided this claim in his favour for Rs. 41,77,809 plus 9% interest. All other claims were rejected for lack of proof (no timely protest, no real evidence).

Decided 28 Oct 2026Read case
Civil ProcedureDelhi High Court

Kasturi Rajan & Ors. vs. Vatsala Vescio & Ors.

The Court held the original request was conditional, not an irreversible abandonment, and under Supreme Court precedent (Rajendra Prasad Gupta), a court's inherent power allows withdrawing even a withdrawal request unless the law expressly forbids it. It upheld advancing the hearing date given the 16-year pendency and the plaintiff's age.

Decided 28 Oct 2026Read case
Ritu Goel & Anr. vs. Kamlesh & Ors. – Case Summary