A K Enterprises vs. New Modern Vuildwell Pvt Ltd
Background
A K Enterprises said it had done electrical work for the respondent company on several projects under a series of connected agreements, and that about Rs. 76.84 lakh remained unpaid. It sent a demand notice and then a notice invoking arbitration (a private dispute-resolution process decided by a neutral arbitrator instead of a court), but the company did not pay or agree on an arbitrator. A K Enterprises then asked the High Court to appoint one.
Decision Breakdown
The company's lawyer argued the claims were time-barred and that the agreements were separate contracts that could not be bundled into one case. Even so, while keeping all those objections alive, he agreed to the appointment of a sole arbitrator, on the condition that the petitioner bear the arbitrator's full fees and expenses because it had come to court late. The petitioner accepted this without giving up its own rights. With both sides' consent, the Court referred the disputes to arbitration under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, appointed an advocate as sole arbitrator under the Delhi International Arbitration Centre (DIAC) and its rules, and left every objection on limitation, misjoinder and merits for the arbitrator to decide. The parties were told to approach DIAC within two weeks.
Lesson Learnt
When a contract has an arbitration clause and the other side will not agree on an arbitrator, the High Court can appoint one. Agreeing to arbitration does not mean giving up objections such as delay, which the arbitrator can still decide.