Birendra Kumar Agrawal v. S2 Tech.com India Pvt. Ltd.
Background
Manjeera Constructions Ltd. (MCL), a corporate guarantor, went into insolvency, and its Committee of Creditors approved the resolution plan of Valentis Laboratories Pvt. Ltd. (VLPL) with a 91.64% vote on 10.06.2024. S2 Tech.com, a creditor holding only a 3.3% vote, objected that VLPL had not paid its earnest money deposit on time; the NCLT rejected that objection on 30.07.2024 and later approved VLPL's plan on 26.03.2025. S2 Tech.com appealed to the NCLAT (the appellate insolvency tribunal) but never made VLPL a party, yet on 19.03.2026 the NCLAT declared VLPL's plan invalid and issued directions to the Resolution Professional.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court set aside the NCLAT's judgment of 19.03.2026 on the sole ground that it breached natural justice: VLPL, the party most seriously affected, lost its approved plan without ever being heard, a "flagrant violation" of audi alteram partem (the rule that no one should be condemned unheard). The Court noted the NCLAT had also gone far beyond the issues raised and had ignored that the NCLT had already approved the plan, an approval S2 Tech.com never challenged. Rather than send the matter back, the Court left all issues, including the earnest-money question, open to be decided in the separate appeals against the NCLT's 26.03.2025 approval order that are already pending before the NCLAT. The appeals were disposed of, with parties bearing their own costs.
Lesson Learnt
A court or tribunal cannot take away someone's rights without first giving that person a chance to be heard. If you challenge a decision that benefits another party, you must make that party a respondent, or any order you win is liable to be set aside.