Twinstar Technologies Ltd. v. Bank of Maharashtra
Background
Videocon Industries Ltd. (VIL) and twelve group companies went into a combined insolvency process, with admitted claims of about Rs. 64,838 crore. Twinstar Technologies' resolution plan, offering Rs. 2,962.02 crore (a haircut of about 95.85%), was approved by 95.09% of the lenders, but most of the money to lenders was to come as debentures (NCDs) redeemable over six years rather than cash. Bank of Maharashtra, IFCI and SIDBI, who voted against the plan, objected; the appellate tribunal (NCLAT) set the approval aside in January 2022 and sent the plan back to the Committee of Creditors (CoC), which itself had asked to reconsider. In a second group of appeals, the promoter Venugopal Dhoot and a vendors' association argued that Videocon's foreign oil and gas assets in Brazil and Indonesia, held through subsidiaries, should be counted as part of VIL's insolvency.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court dismissed all the appeals. It held that "payment" to lenders who vote against a plan must be payment in money (following Jaypee Kensington), so a plan that leaves them to be paid through six-year debentures, with only a general promise to "comply with the law", breaches Section 30(2)(b) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code; the NCLT could not fix this itself by ordering cash payment, as that rewrote the plan. The NCLAT was right to send the plan back to the CoC, which does not stop existing ("functus officio") once it approves a plan and could reconsider while appeals were pending; the Court also found that Competition Commission approval had in fact been obtained on time. On the foreign assets, it held that a holding company and even a wholly owned subsidiary are separate legal persons, so the subsidiaries' assets are not VIL's, and the promoter, who had himself asked to keep those assets out, could not now take a contrary stand. The Court also laid down guidelines for when the NCLAT should send approved plans back to lenders: only for a real legal defect, sparingly, and with strict timelines.
Lesson Learnt
In an insolvency, creditors who vote against a resolution plan are entitled to their minimum share in actual money, not in long-dated paper, and tribunals cannot rewrite a plan: they can only send it back to the lenders to fix. A parent company does not legally own its subsidiaries' assets, and a party who takes one position in court cannot later take the opposite one to suit itself.