Lulu International Shopping Malls Pvt. Ltd. v. Gorinka Pratyusha
Background
Lulu International won the insolvency process of Manjeera Retail Holdings, a mall developer; its resolution plan (rescue plan) was approved by 100% of creditors and by the NCLT on 26.03.2025, and Lulu says it invested Rs. 271.52 crore implementing it. Three buyers of commercial units in Manjeera Mall appealed, saying their full payments were wrongly treated as "advances from customers" rather than as financial-creditor claims. The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Section 61(2)) allows 30 days to appeal plus at most 15 more days if delay is excused; the buyers filed on day 46 (Sunday, 11.05.2025), and the appellate tribunal (NCLAT) accepted the appeals because day 45 fell on a second-Saturday holiday, and then refused Lulu's application to recall that decision.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court allowed Lulu's appeals, set aside the NCLAT's orders, and dismissed the buyers' appeals as time-barred. Following its earlier ruling in Tata Steel Ltd. v. Raj Kumar Banerjee (2025), it held that the "court holiday" extension under Section 4 of the Limitation Act applies only to the basic 30-day period, not to the extra 15-day discretionary window. The NCLAT was also wrong to treat Tata Steel as a later decision, since it predated the NCLAT's order, and while the NCLAT has no power of review, it does have inherent power to recall its own orders and should have used it; in any case the buyers e-filed on a Sunday, so they could equally have filed on the Saturday. The Court rejected the argument that the delay-condonation order had become final, since the recall application kept the issue alive.
Lesson Learnt
Insolvency appeal deadlines are strict: 30 days plus a maximum of 15 extra days, and a holiday on the last day of the extra period does not buy one more day. If you plan to appeal in an insolvency case, file well before the outer limit, especially when e-filing makes it possible on holidays too.