Ganesh Benzoplast Ltd. v. State Trading Corporation of India
Background
Ganesh Benzoplast, a Maharashtra chemicals and storage company, was declared a "sick" company in 2010 and a rehabilitation scheme was approved by the Delhi High Court in 2015; under it, unsecured creditors would be paid only 25% of their principal dues. The State Trading Corporation (STC) was not listed as an unsecured creditor but only as a "contingent liability" (a claim not yet confirmed), and it never objected to this. In 2018 STC demanded about Rs. 24.26 crore and filed an insolvency petition; the NCLT instead directed the company to pay 25% of the dues (Rs. 2,18,88,421), which STC accepted "without prejudice", but the appellate tribunal (NCLAT) later revived STC's insolvency petition for fresh hearing.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court allowed the company's appeal, set aside the NCLAT judgment of 21.01.2026 and restored the NCLT order of 13.02.2020. It held that STC, having accepted its "contingent liability" status without challenge, could at best become an unsecured creditor once its claim was confirmed, and even then could claim only 25% of its principal dues. Relying on Modi Rubber Ltd. v. Continental Carbon India Ltd. and Fertilizer Corporation of India v. Coromandel Sacks, the Court said an approved rehabilitation scheme binds all creditors, so the scheme's option to "wait seven years and then claim full dues" was not valid. Since STC had already received the maximum it could ever get under the scheme, nothing was left to decide in its insolvency petition. Parties were left to bear their own costs.
Lesson Learnt
Once a court-approved rehabilitation scheme scales down creditors' dues, every creditor is bound by it and cannot later use insolvency proceedings to recover the full amount. If you disagree with how your claim is classified in such a scheme, object at the time: staying silent can cost you the right to complain later.