Ganesh Benzoplast Ltd. v. State Trading Corporation of India

Civil Appeal · 2026 INSC 1223Decided 16 Nov 2026
Civil Appeal No. 3097 of 2026
Justice Sanjay Kumar · Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva

Background

Ganesh Benzoplast, a Maharashtra chemicals and storage company, was declared a "sick" company in 2010 and a rehabilitation scheme was approved by the Delhi High Court in 2015; under it, unsecured creditors would be paid only 25% of their principal dues. The State Trading Corporation (STC) was not listed as an unsecured creditor but only as a "contingent liability" (a claim not yet confirmed), and it never objected to this. In 2018 STC demanded about Rs. 24.26 crore and filed an insolvency petition; the NCLT instead directed the company to pay 25% of the dues (Rs. 2,18,88,421), which STC accepted "without prejudice", but the appellate tribunal (NCLAT) later revived STC's insolvency petition for fresh hearing.

Decision Breakdown

The Supreme Court allowed the company's appeal, set aside the NCLAT judgment of 21.01.2026 and restored the NCLT order of 13.02.2020. It held that STC, having accepted its "contingent liability" status without challenge, could at best become an unsecured creditor once its claim was confirmed, and even then could claim only 25% of its principal dues. Relying on Modi Rubber Ltd. v. Continental Carbon India Ltd. and Fertilizer Corporation of India v. Coromandel Sacks, the Court said an approved rehabilitation scheme binds all creditors, so the scheme's option to "wait seven years and then claim full dues" was not valid. Since STC had already received the maximum it could ever get under the scheme, nothing was left to decide in its insolvency petition. Parties were left to bear their own costs.

Lesson Learnt

Once a court-approved rehabilitation scheme scales down creditors' dues, every creditor is bound by it and cannot later use insolvency proceedings to recover the full amount. If you disagree with how your claim is classified in such a scheme, object at the time: staying silent can cost you the right to complain later.

Company & Insolvency LawSupreme Court of India

Birendra Kumar Agrawal v. S2 Tech.com India Pvt. Ltd.

The Supreme Court set aside the NCLAT's judgment of 19.03.2026 on the sole ground that it breached natural justice: VLPL, the party most seriously affected, lost its approved plan without ever being heard, a "flagrant violation" of audi alteram partem (the rule that no one should be condemned unheard). The Court noted the NCLAT had also gone far beyond the issues raised and had ignored that the NCLT had already approved the plan, an approval S2 Tech.com never challenged. Rather than send the matter back, the Court left all issues, including the earnest-money question, open to be decided in the separate appeals against the NCLT's 26.03.2025 approval order that are already pending before the NCLAT. The appeals were disposed of, with parties bearing their own costs.

Decided 16 Nov 2026Read case
Company & Insolvency LawSupreme Court of India

Lulu International Shopping Malls Pvt. Ltd. v. Gorinka Pratyusha

The Supreme Court allowed Lulu's appeals, set aside the NCLAT's orders, and dismissed the buyers' appeals as time-barred. Following its earlier ruling in Tata Steel Ltd. v. Raj Kumar Banerjee (2025), it held that the "court holiday" extension under Section 4 of the Limitation Act applies only to the basic 30-day period, not to the extra 15-day discretionary window. The NCLAT was also wrong to treat Tata Steel as a later decision, since it predated the NCLAT's order, and while the NCLAT has no power of review, it does have inherent power to recall its own orders and should have used it; in any case the buyers e-filed on a Sunday, so they could equally have filed on the Saturday. The Court rejected the argument that the delay-condonation order had become final, since the recall application kept the issue alive.

Decided 16 Nov 2026Read case
Company & Insolvency LawSupreme Court of India

Elaine Info Solutions Pvt. Ltd. v. J & A Avenues India Pvt. Ltd.

The Supreme Court allowed the buyer's appeal, set aside both tribunal orders and dismissed the mother's petition. It held that an outside buyer cannot be expected to prove whether a company's internal board meeting actually took place: under the "Doctrine of Indoor Management" (outsiders dealing in good faith may assume a company's internal procedures were properly followed), a buyer acts in good faith when a 50% director-shareholder produces a board resolution. Crucially, the company's audited accounts, signed by the mother herself on 02.09.2016, recorded the sale and the receipt and use of the sale money, so she could not claim ignorance; her 2018 petition challenging a 2015 registered sale deed was also filed after more than three years. The son's separate appeal was dismissed as infructuous (his five-year director ban had already run out), and the Court left the pending civil suit over the sale price to be decided on its own merits.

Decided 16 Nov 2026Read case
Company & Insolvency LawSupreme Court of India

Twinstar Technologies Ltd. v. Bank of Maharashtra

The Supreme Court dismissed all the appeals. It held that "payment" to lenders who vote against a plan must be payment in money (following Jaypee Kensington), so a plan that leaves them to be paid through six-year debentures, with only a general promise to "comply with the law", breaches Section 30(2)(b) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code; the NCLT could not fix this itself by ordering cash payment, as that rewrote the plan. The NCLAT was right to send the plan back to the CoC, which does not stop existing ("functus officio") once it approves a plan and could reconsider while appeals were pending; the Court also found that Competition Commission approval had in fact been obtained on time. On the foreign assets, it held that a holding company and even a wholly owned subsidiary are separate legal persons, so the subsidiaries' assets are not VIL's, and the promoter, who had himself asked to keep those assets out, could not now take a contrary stand. The Court also laid down guidelines for when the NCLAT should send approved plans back to lenders: only for a real legal defect, sparingly, and with strict timelines.

Decided 16 Nov 2026Read case
Company & Insolvency LawSupreme Court of India

ECL Finance Ltd. and Anr. v. Abhinav Mukherjee and Ors. (with connected matters)

The Supreme Court upheld the exclusion, holding the "related party" threshold is lower than the control test used for resolution-applicant eligibility: merely having a genuine role in the debtor's policy-making is enough. The lender held sweeping powers (appointing directors, control over budgets and unit sales, control over escrow accounts) going well beyond passive creditor protections. The Court also rejected a late assignment of the loan to another entity as a bona-fide transfer, finding it was made only to circumvent the related-party bar after insolvency proceedings had already begun.

Decided 27 Oct 2026Read case
Company & Insolvency LawSupreme Court of India

Bank of India & Ors. v. S.M. Kamal Pasha & Ors.

The Supreme Court upheld the appellate tribunal's ruling that creditors cannot unilaterally withdraw an already-approved Resolution Plan merely because the debtor's fortunes later improved: once approved and placed before the Tribunal, the plan becomes binding under the IBC's statutory framework, not ordinary contract law, and the withdrawal route applies only before approval, not after. The Court left it to the Tribunal to decide both the winning bidder's confirmation request and the promoters' competing settlement application on the merits.

Decided 26 Oct 2026Read case
Ganesh Benzoplast Ltd. v. State Trading Corporation of India