Elaine Info Solutions Pvt. Ltd. v. J & A Avenues India Pvt. Ltd.
Background
A small family company owned equally by a mother and her son (its only two directors and shareholders) sold 9 acres 28 guntas of land to Elaine Info Solutions in September 2015, with the son signing the sale deed on the strength of a board resolution dated 01.08.2015. In 2018 the mother went to the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) under Section 241 of the Companies Act, 2013, saying no board meeting had ever been held and she knew nothing of the sale. The NCLT declared the resolution and sale deed void, ordered the land restored to the company and the price of Rs. 4,36,50,000 refunded with 8% interest, and barred the son as a director for five years; the appellate tribunal (NCLAT) upheld this.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court allowed the buyer's appeal, set aside both tribunal orders and dismissed the mother's petition. It held that an outside buyer cannot be expected to prove whether a company's internal board meeting actually took place: under the "Doctrine of Indoor Management" (outsiders dealing in good faith may assume a company's internal procedures were properly followed), a buyer acts in good faith when a 50% director-shareholder produces a board resolution. Crucially, the company's audited accounts, signed by the mother herself on 02.09.2016, recorded the sale and the receipt and use of the sale money, so she could not claim ignorance; her 2018 petition challenging a 2015 registered sale deed was also filed after more than three years. The son's separate appeal was dismissed as infructuous (his five-year director ban had already run out), and the Court left the pending civil suit over the sale price to be decided on its own merits.
Lesson Learnt
A person who buys from a company in good faith on the basis of a board resolution produced by its director is generally protected; disputes about whether internal meetings were held are for the company's own insiders to answer. And if you sign your company's accounts recording a transaction, you cannot later claim you never knew about it.