ECL Finance Ltd. and Anr. v. Abhinav Mukherjee and Ors. (with connected matters)
Background
A lender (ECL Finance) and a debenture trustee claimed financial-creditor status and sat on the Committee of Creditors of a company that had guaranteed debt it issued, backed by extensive mortgages and control rights. A homebuyer challenged their presence on the committee as "related parties" of the debtor, a challenge the tribunals upheld.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court upheld the exclusion, holding the "related party" threshold is lower than the control test used for resolution-applicant eligibility: merely having a genuine role in the debtor's policy-making is enough. The lender held sweeping powers (appointing directors, control over budgets and unit sales, control over escrow accounts) going well beyond passive creditor protections. The Court also rejected a late assignment of the loan to another entity as a bona-fide transfer, finding it was made only to circumvent the related-party bar after insolvency proceedings had already begun.
Lesson Learnt
A lender that negotiates extensive control rights over a borrower's management and finances risks being classified as a "related party" and losing its seat on the creditors' committee: a status that cannot be escaped by assigning the debt to another entity after insolvency proceedings begin.