Chatur Singh Dhruw v. The State of Chhattisgarh and Ors. (with connected SLP)

Civil Appeal · 2026 INSC 1205Decided 6 Nov 2026
Civil Appeal No. 14172 of 2026
Justice Manmohan · Justice Shree Chandrashekhar

Background

Two government clerical employees were compulsorily retired in the public interest after a Screening Committee scored their service records below benchmark, based largely on declining Annual Confidential Reports in their final years. Their challenges failed before the Chhattisgarh High Court.

Decision Breakdown

The Supreme Court upheld the retirements, holding compulsory retirement isn't punitive, so natural-justice safeguards don't apply, and courts only check whether the decision rested on relevant material and fair criteria uniformly applied, not whether it was the right call. It rejected the selective treatment argument, since there is no right to negative equality just because a colleague escaped action, and held uncommunicated adverse appraisal entries can still validly justify compulsory retirement, distinguishing cases about promotion decisions.

Lesson Learnt

A government employee's compulsory retirement can't be challenged merely because it wasn't communicated in advance or because a similarly placed colleague wasn't also retired: courts only interfere if the decision was arbitrary or lacked any evidentiary basis.

Service & Administrative LawSupreme Court of India

In Re: Phalodi Accident v. National Highways Authority of India

This is not a final judgment: it clarifies earlier directions in a case that is still pending. The Court clarified that its 13 April 2026 directions addressed the general problem of highway encroachments and did not decide whether any particular building was an encroachment. Authorities must still follow the procedure in Section 26 of the Control of National Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002 (notice, a chance to object, and consideration of the objection) and cannot cite the Court's order as a shortcut around the law. Since ownership, boundary and acquisition disputes need examination of revenue records and surveys, the Court sent the applicants to their respective High Courts and expressed no view on the merits. Until those cases are decided, no demolition or coercive action may be taken on the disputed structures, but this protection creates no rights in the applicants' favour and permits no new construction; the original directions otherwise remain in force.

Decided 18 Nov 2026Read case
Service & Administrative LawSupreme Court of India

Ashok Kumar v. Central Bank of India

The Supreme Court agreed that the miscellaneous application was not maintainable: such an application in a finally decided case can only deal with ancillary matters like correcting clerical errors or clarifying an order, not a new substantive claim like interest. However, it held that the claim for interest was not barred by "res judicata" (the rule against re-litigating decided matters), because it arose from a separate, later cause of action (the delay during the litigation), and the High Court had wrongly dismissed his 2015 writ petition; he should have appealed that dismissal. Noting that interest is not a penalty but a normal accretion on money, that "an act of court should harm no litigant," and that he was now a septuagenarian who had spent over four decades in litigation, the Court used its special powers under Article 142 of the Constitution to direct the Bank to pay him an additional Rs. 5 lakh within two months as full and final settlement. The appeal was disposed of on these terms.

Decided 18 Nov 2026Read case
Service & Administrative LawSupreme Court of India

Prithviraj S. Singh (Deceased) Through LRs v. Secretary, School Education Department, State of Maharashtra

The Supreme Court noted that a party must plead its case, and the clerks' arguments on the merits went beyond what their writ petitions said, so strictly the appeal could have been dismissed. But it found it a matter of serious concern that the school ignored the High Court's consent order: there was effectively no evidence before the Tribunal to prove the charges, and the non-supply of inquiry reports was itself a serious flaw. Applying the principle that an action contrary to an express judicial order is a nullity, and using its special power under Article 142 of the Constitution (to do complete justice), the Court directed the school to pay each appellant (the heirs in the case of the deceased clerk) Rs. 10,00,000 as lump-sum compensation for wrongful termination within three months, as full and final settlement, with 12% annual interest if paid late.

Decided 18 Nov 2026Read case
Service & Administrative LawSupreme Court of India

U.P. Ground Water Department Non Gazetted Employee Association v. Chief Secretary

The Supreme Court declared both the 2021 and 2025 Validation Acts unconstitutional. It held that a legislature may cure the defect a court has identified, but cannot simply put the same exclusion in "a new statutory dress" and declare a final judgment ineffective; these Acts changed the label but kept the very discrimination Prem Singh had struck down. It rejected the State's plea of a heavy financial burden, noting that money found for park beautification cannot rank above legal obligations owed to employees. It directed that eligible retirees may apply with their service details and the authority must decide within six months (with a hearing and reasoned order before any rejection), with arrears limited to three years as in Prem Singh, except for heirs of employees who died before Prem Singh was decided; late payment attracts 9% simple interest. The benefits apply to all eligible employees whether or not they belong to the petitioning association, and in the pending contempt cases the State was given a final six months to pay what is due under Prem Singh.

Decided 18 Nov 2026Read case
Service & Administrative LawDelhi High Court

M/s R.B. Saxena and Sons vs. East Delhi Municipal Corporation & Ors. and connected matters

The Court found that EDMC itself admitted the tender was for foul condition work at the Rs. 297 rate, and its own Executive Engineer had told the auditors there was no irregularity. It held that leaving the clause out of the work orders was a clerical mistake, that the other two corporations formed from the same tender kept paying the higher rate, and that EDMC gave no show cause notice before deducting. This made the deductions arbitrary and in breach of Article 14 of the Constitution (the right to equal and fair treatment by the State). The Court rejected the objection of delay, noting one contractor had gone to court repeatedly since 2016, the others had filed within time of the February 2018 demand, and the Supreme Court's COVID-period limitation extension covered the 2021 petition. It also held that a writ petition (a direct petition to the High Court against a State body) can be heard in a contract dispute where the State acts arbitrarily and the facts are admitted. EDMC's recovery letters were set aside and it was directed to refund all deducted amounts with 8% annual interest.

Decided 18 Nov 2026Read case
Service & Administrative LawSupreme Court of India

Ku. Kiran Bhujade v. Sudhir Shikshan Sanstha

The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, set aside the High Court judgment and restored the Tribunal's order of reinstatement with continuity of service and full back wages. It held that the test is not whether actual bias is proved but whether a fair-minded person would see a "reasonable likelihood of bias", and that close family ties can disqualify an adjudicator. Here there was a "total familial capture" of the inquiry: the complainant, chief witness and prosecutor gave evidence before his own brother as judge, which breaks the rule that no one should be a judge in their own cause and violates Article 14. Following procedures such as hearings and cross-examination cannot cure such bias, the "doctrine of necessity" did not apply because two unrelated committee members were available, and she had not waived her objection since she raised it at every stage. The Court also directed the Education Officer to consider absorbing her in another fully government-aided school.

Decided 17 Nov 2026Read case
Chatur Singh Dhruw v. The State of Chhattisgarh and Ors…