Chatur Singh Dhruw v. The State of Chhattisgarh and Ors. (with connected SLP)
Background
Two government clerical employees were compulsorily retired in the public interest after a Screening Committee scored their service records below benchmark, based largely on declining Annual Confidential Reports in their final years. Their challenges failed before the Chhattisgarh High Court.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court upheld the retirements, holding compulsory retirement isn't punitive, so natural-justice safeguards don't apply, and courts only check whether the decision rested on relevant material and fair criteria uniformly applied, not whether it was the right call. It rejected the selective treatment argument, since there is no right to negative equality just because a colleague escaped action, and held uncommunicated adverse appraisal entries can still validly justify compulsory retirement, distinguishing cases about promotion decisions.
Lesson Learnt
A government employee's compulsory retirement can't be challenged merely because it wasn't communicated in advance or because a similarly placed colleague wasn't also retired: courts only interfere if the decision was arbitrary or lacked any evidentiary basis.