Devdutt & Ors. vs. Union of India
Background
A man died after apparently falling from a running EMU train near Ghaziabad in 2018. His children's compensation claim was dismissed by the Railway Claims Tribunal, relying on the absence of a ticket on his body and a railway inquiry report (filed over five years late) concluding he was trespassing on the tracks.
Decision Breakdown
The Court held absence of a ticket doesn't by itself disprove genuine passenger status: the burden shifts to the Railways to disprove it. The evidence proved a train-related injury but not that he was crossing the tracks rather than falling from a moving train, and the five-years-late inquiry report carried little weight since Railways can't benefit from its own delay. The dismissal was set aside and remanded for compensation calculation.
Lesson Learnt
A family doesn't have to produce the deceased's actual ticket: once basic facts suggest genuine travel, it's the Railways' job to prove otherwise.