Rani Devi vs. Union of India
Background
A woman mistakenly boarded the wrong train; ticket staff took her ticket since the train didn't stop at her destination, and she says she was then forcibly pushed off the moving train, losing her leg. The Tribunal rejected her claim, holding she wasn't a genuine passenger and had probably jumped deliberately.
Decision Breakdown
The Court held lack of a physical ticket can't defeat her claim where railway records (a station superintendent's memo, the train manager's statement) independently confirmed a woman fell from that train at that station. The "jumped deliberately" theory was an unproven inference, and negligence differs legally from deliberate self-inflicted injury. The dismissal was overturned and remanded for compensation.
Lesson Learnt
Being unable to produce your ticket, especially with an explanation, doesn't automatically disqualify a genuine accident victim, and courts shouldn't assume deliberate self-harm without real proof.